A federal appellate court on Tuesday upheld the conviction of Alfredo Sararo, a former Monroeville tennis star and county probation officer sentenced to nine years in prison for ripping off wealthy Pittsburghers in bogus Florida real estate deals by capitalizing on his relationship with a retired county judge, Robert Horgos.

A three-judge panel of the 11th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, which heard oral argument in the case last week, affirmed the conviction in a terse ruling, saying only that "we conclude that all of Sararo's arguments lack merit."

Mr. Sararo, who was convicted in federal court in Florida in 2012, has repeatedly accused the government of misconduct in the way it used its key witness, Mr. Horgos, to prosecute him, saying Assistant U.S. Attorney Brendan Conway showed "callous disregard" for his rights by allowing "perjured testimony" by Mr. Horgos.

Mr. Horgos testified against his former friend under a grant of immunity.

Advertise with us

Mr. Sararo argued that the deal was improper because he said Mr. Horgos was never a victim and had downplayed his own role in misleading his affluent Pittsburgh friends into investing in fake South Florida property deals. Mr. Sararo said that Mr. Horgos lied on the stand and that the government knew he was lying.

But Mr. Conway described Mr. Sararo as a con man who used his relationship with Mr. Horgos to victimize the judge, his family and his friends, including another judge, Gerard Bigley, Pittsburgh lawyers Sam Kamin and his son, Jonathan, and others.

U.S. District Judge John Steele sentenced Mr. Sararo last year to nine years in prison, well below what the prosecution wanted, and set the fraud loss at $2.5 million.

Mr. Horgos has maintained that he lost $1.2 million to Mr. Sararo and had to dip into his pension to save his Sewickley Hills home. During an interview at his house earlier this year, he said Mr. Sararo took advantage of him and consistently conned him out of his money.