A Millvale police officer convicted of violating the rights of a handcuffed prisoner was disappointed by the outcome of the trial in U.S. District Court, her attorney said Wednesday.

A jury found Officer Nicole Murphy guilty of violating the prisoner’s rights by tasing him repeatedly as he sat on the floor of the police station two years ago.

Officer Murphy, 30, who is suspended from her job, did not testify and said nothing as she left the courtroom.

“We’re extremely disappointed,” said her lawyer, Robert Stewart. “This was as strong a federal case as I’ve had.”

Advertise with us

Federal prosecutors said Officer Murphy used her Taser on Thomas Smith three times without justification as he sat handcuffed on the floor and drunkenly smacked his head against a cubicle divider on Sept. 21, 2012.

Cindy Chung, an assistant U.S. attorney, told the jury that Mr. Smith was no danger to anyone and didn’t need to be tased, arguing that Officer Murphy shocked him because she was irritated at his taunts as she tried to complete paperwork regarding his arrest for public drunkenness.

Mr. Stewart argued in court, however, that she shocked him to keep him from hurting himself and to protect herself and her partner, former officer Casey Bonincontro, from Mr. Smith's “escalating” violence. In her reports, Officer Murphy wrote that Mr. Smith resisted arrest, spat on Mr. Bonincontro and then kicked her in the chest.

Mr. Bonincontro, who recorded part of the incident on his cell phone, said Mr. Smith didn’t assault anyone, didn’t spit on anyone and was under control when Officer Murphy zapped him, twice using the weapon’s drive-stun mode and once on probe-stun, in which the barbs lodged in his back and shocked him.

“That wasn't cool,” Mr. Bonincontro said he later told his partner after they had dropped Mr. Smith off at the Allegheny County Jail. “I know,” he said she replied.

Advertise with us

But Mr. Stewart said Mr. Bonincontro was not a credible witness.

In court he criticized him for sitting on a chair recording the incident and laughing at Mr. Smith instead of doing his job to pull him away from the divider to keep him from smacking his head. Instead, two paramedics are seen in the video pulling Mr. Smith away.

Mr. Stewart also questioned how Mr. Bonincontro could say he did not see Mr. Smith kick Officer Murphy when both paramedics said they saw a kick, although it apparently occurred while Officer Murphy was zapping him with the Taser the first time and is not visible in the video.

Mr. Stewart also tried to undermine Mr. Bonincontro by questioning him about a protection-from-abuse order he had received involving a 17-year-old girl, saying he had not reported the order to Bridgeville police when he applied for a job there even though it meant he temporarily could not carry a gun.

“He was a liar, and he got caught in about 10 lies,” Mr. Stewart said of the former officer after the verdict. “I think the fact that she used that Taser on someone that was handcuffed was enough for that jury.”

U.S. District Judge Arthur Schwab set sentencing for March 13. Officer Murphy faces a potential 10-year sentence, and can never be a police officer again.