A former Millvale police officer convicted of repeatedly zapping a drunk and handcuffed prisoner with a Taser was sentenced Friday to a year of home detention and ordered to spend 300 hours talking to cops about excessive force even though she told the judge that she still doesn’t think she did anything wrong.
U.S. District Judge Arthur Schwab gave Nicole Murphy a total of three years of probation, with the first year on home confinement, after rejecting the government's request for at least 27 months in federal prison.
“It was what we wanted,” said her lawyer, Phil DiLucente, who argued that Murphy, as a single mother, needs to be home to take care of her 10-year-old daughter. “We're very pleased with this sentence, even though this is a somber day.”
Murphy’s family and friends, including several police officers from Swissvale, Homestead and other communities, hugged and celebrated in the hallway after a marathon sentencing hearing.
The U.S. Attorney’s office had no immediate comment on whether prosecutors will appeal.
Judge Schwab noted that Murphy’s offense was serious, but he said sending her to prison would serve no purpose.
In court, she told the judge that she had been offered a plea by the U.S. Attorney’s office but didn’t take it because she didn’t want to lie by pleading guilty when she believed she wasn’t. So she went to trial and lost.
The judge said she has to perform 100 hours of talking to police about the use of force and the impact of her case on her life in each of the years of her probation at the direction of the U.S. probation office.
Numerous friends, including police officers and 911 center employees, wrote letters on her behalf, saying she is an honest person and deserves a break.
Among them were Reserve Sgt. James Etherington, Ross Officer Warren Lillie II and Jason Hall, a Pittsburgh police officer. Two 911 supervisors, Michael Moore and Craig Bopes, also wrote letters, as did 911 communications officers Lucas Bark, Erin Rozum and George Dietz.
A jury in November found Murphy guilty of violating Thomas Smith’s rights by shocking him three times in September 2012.
Federal prosecutors said she used her stun gun on Smith without justification as he sat handcuffed on the floor and drunkenly smacked his head against a cubicle divider.
In court Friday, Assistant U.S. Attorney Cindy Chung asked for jail time as a deterrent to other officers who might be tempted to use excessive force, saying a police officer should not be awarded special treatment.
She also introduced Murphy’s personnel history at the Millvale department, which includes warnings and suspensions for failing to write reports, failing to show up for work and missing court dates that in some cases resulted in magistrates’ dismissing charges.
Ms. Chung also noted that Murphy had been arrested on a charge of drunk driving in Ross in 2011.
Torsten Ove: tove@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1510.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.