The government and a lawyer for a Millvale police officer charged with violating a handcuffed man’s civil rights by shocking him with her Taser are sparring over whether the jury in her upcoming trial will hear evidence of her prior arrest for driving drunk and her “fraternization” with a known criminal.
Nicole Murphy, 30, is set to go on trial in U.S. District Court on Nov. 17, accused of shocking a drunken Thomas Smith as he sat on the police station floor in handcuffs and began smacking his head against the leg of a desk.
Officer Murphy and her lawyer, Robert Stewart, argue that she shocked Mr. Smith to keep him from hurting himself any further. The government says she abused her power as a police officer and deprived Mr. Smith of his rights.
Beyond that dispute, however, the parties also disagree about what else the jury may hear about Officer Murphy.
In motions filed this week, both raised the issue of whether her DUI arrest three years ago or her association with a man with a drug-related criminal record can be presented.
The debate started in September when the U.S. attorney’s office and the Justice Department told Officer Murphy’s lawyer that they intended to introduce evidence of both issues.
Read More
Mr. Stewart objected, saying her past conduct has nothing to do with the crime charged and shouldn’t be part of the case under federal rules of evidence.
The government said in response Tuesday that it will not present the evidence directly but will bring the matters up on cross-examination if Mr. Stewart is allowed to present testimony about Officer Murphy’s commendations or positive job evaluations.
Officer Murphy was charged in 2011 with drunken driving and went through the accelerated rehabilitative disposition program for first-time offenders, or ARD, after which her record was expunged.
The government said she has also carried on a relationship with a man despite knowing about his drug record.
Officer Murphy is on unpaid leave pending the outcome of the case.
Millvale paid $37,500 to settle Mr. Smith’s related lawsuit against her and the borough.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.