Butler County has formally asked the state to conduct a broader audit of a juvenile detention facility at the center of a bribery scandal in Luzerne County.

Controller Jack McMillin and the Butler County commissioners made the request of the state Department of Public Welfare in July.

"We want them to audit the entire period in which Butler County was doing business with Western Pennsylvania Childcare," Mr. McMillin said.

The final report from the welfare department on the Allegheny Township facility and its sister center -- Pennsylvania Child Care in Pittston, Luzerne County -- determined that customers were charged too much. That audit looked at only a one-year period beginning July 1, 2008. Mr. McMillin wants a more comprehensive review, going back to the opening of Western Pennsylvania Childcare in 2005. Butler County didn't deal with the Luzerne facility, but only the one in Allegheny Township.

Advertise with us

The facilities are owned by Greg Zappala, brother of Allegheny County district attorney Stephen A. Zappala Jr. and son of former state Supreme Court Justice Stephen A. Zappala Sr.

The audit enumerates about $1.2 million in unallowable expenses, such as golf outings and a chartered fishing trip, inflated fees that were passed on to counties that contracted with Western Pennsylvania Childcare and with Pennsylvania Childcare.

Counties were billed $314 a day for secure treatment and $255 a day for shelter services. Auditors determined the fees could have been $64 and $60 less, respectively. Mr. Zappala contended in his response to the draft audit that the lower numbers do not allow any profit margin. The report notes that Mr. Zappala's audit response "did not ... support any changes to the total costs determined as allowable."

Two Luzerne County judges are in jail for taking $2.6 million in payoffs to direct business to the facilities. Greg Zappala is not accused of wrongdoing.

Butler County has held back about $30,000 in fees, and no money will be released, Mr. McMillin said, until his staff determines what the county has a right to claim.