HARRISBURG -- A judge has determined that state Rep. Jeff Habay committed substantial -- but not criminal -- violations of the state's Election Code by failing to fully report the source of numerous campaign donations, including a big contribution from House Republicans that covered some of Habay's nagging legal bills.

Commonwealth Court Judge Robert Simpson, who delivered the judgment Thursday, was tapped to referee a summer audit of Habay's campaign finance records.

The unconventional audit hearing was sought by residents of Habay's legislative district, including George Radich, who is married to Rebecca Radich, one of Habay's former employees.

Habay, a Shaler Republican completing his fifth House term, fired Rebecca years ago. He's maintained all along that the Radiches have an ax to grind, angry over her dismissal.

Advertise with us

Radich believes the mistakes were reckless, the result of a representative who wasn't particularly careful with his checkbook and a campaign treasurer who didn't know how to do her job.

Habay's attorney, John D. Sheridan, said the judge's findings were mostly inconsequential, and that Habay admitted to the reporting errors during the audit hearing.

"Overall, it's a good opinion," Sheridan said. "The judge found no willful criminal intent."

The judge did, however, find substantial negligence on the part of Habay's treasurer. "He calls it negligence, I call it human error," Sheridan said.

Despite Simpson's finding of no criminal negligence, he's forwarding the audit results to the Allegheny County district attorney's office for "further action, if any, as he shall deem necessary." Habay also has to pay the costs incurred by the Radich team -- about $62.

Advertise with us

The end of the audit doesn't mean the end of Habay's legal problems. In a separate case, he has been charged with two counts of theft of services, and is accused of repeatedly using his legislative staff for re-election campaign work.

Last month, Habay waived his right to a preliminary hearing in that case, meaning it could go to trial.

Prior to that, Habay was ordered by the State Ethics Commission to pay a $13,000 fine for having his office staff campaign on state time, then lying about it. That violates state ethics rules.