Is the life of a child worth $28 million?

No, it's worth far more, said Donna Thomas of Uniontown, who lives on the street where 12-year-old Michael Ellerbe was chased, shot and killed by two Pennsylvania state police troopers after he ran from a stolen car on Dec. 24, 2002.

On Tuesday, a federal jury awarded $28 million to the boy's father, Michael Hickenbottom, and called the shooting a malicious violation of his son's constitutional rights.

"But that's not going to replace the boy," Mrs. Thomas, 63, said ruefully as she stood on her front porch yesterday and recalled her own son's suicide 12 years ago. "Money rules the world, but it doesn't make somebody come back."

Advertise with us

Many neighbors shared her thoughts about a case that still stirs heated emotions here. Some think the award should have been larger; others want to see the two troopers, Samuel Nassan and Juan Curry, go to jail.

"They shouldn't have to kill the boy," said Beth Jones, 33. "They could have shot his butt, his leg, his knee."

During a two-week trial that ended last week, Trooper Nassan testified that he shot at Michael because he thought the boy had fired at his partner. Cpl. Curry, who has since been promoted, said his own gun went off accidentally as he climbed a fence to chase Michael.

Police officers are taught to aim at a central point on a target's body to avoid the danger of stray bullets, the troopers' attorney told jurors. Investigators with both the state police and the FBI determined that the incident didn't warrant criminal charges.

In a statement issued yesterday from State Police headquarters in Harrisburg, the department acknowledged it was a "tragic situation for the family of Michael Ellerbe." But the department also said it stands behind the findings of its investigation and that it will appeal the jury's award.

Advertise with us

The troopers said they encountered Michael in a stolen Ford Bronco on Cleveland Avenue. Instead of obeying their commands, he furiously drove the car in reverse down an alleyway, tearing the siding off an abandoned house before he hit a fence. He then ran from the car, cutting across another alley to reach Edgemont Drive. He crossed Cleveland and clambered over a backyard fence. He was killed in that back yard.

Yesterday, the streets and alleys where the frantic 90-second chase took place were quiet. The abandoned house has been demolished, leaving only a weed-filled plot. A second, larger chain-link fence stands over the fence that both Michael and Cpl. Curry scaled.

"Someone got killed on my property on Christmas Eve. That ain't nothing to talk about," said a man who lives in the house adjacent to the yard. He declined to give his name.

Across the street, 15-year-old Melvin Duley readily retold the story of what he saw out his second-floor window that day. Contradicting the troopers' claims, he said Michael wasn't running with a hand in his pocket. He said he heard three shots, not two.

Melvin also told his version of events during the trial.

Advertise with us

"I'm glad they got a verdict. It was a long time," he said yesterday. "[The troopers] didn't have a right to shoot him."

Melvin and his mother, Elsie Cornish, said officers with the Uniontown Police Department harassed and intimidated them repeatedly after the Ellerbe shooting. In 2006, she sued the department in federal court after an incident in which police accused her of telling her two sons to use BB guns to shoot at a neighbor. She and the department eventually reached a settlement.

Now, they hope to move from Uniontown and start a new life.

Mr. Hickenbottom, a carpenter, has had his own legal problems. On three occasions since his son's shooting he has faced charges of possession of marijuana and related offenses. In two cases he pleaded guilty and was sentenced to probation. He has yet to stand trial in the third.

In 2000, he pleaded guilty to resisting arrest and fleeing police. A charge of reckless endangerment was dropped.

Advertise with us

Yet some neighbors spoke highly of him yesterday. Mrs. Thomas called him a "respectable" man who cared deeply for his son.

Michael also found himself in trouble sometimes, but he still has admirers in the neighborhood. Pictures of the boy with a beaming smile make up a memorial in a display case at Lafayette School, where he was a student.

D'Lavel Elian, 13, said Michael would sometimes come to his Murray Avenue home to help him fix his bicycle.

"He never caused problems around us," D'Lavel said.