The Gateway school board on April 17 formally accepted the resignation of board member Steve O’Donnell, who announced he would be resigning his seat after he was accused of making anti-Semitic remarks to a rabbi at a public meeting.

The board voted 8-0 to accept Mr. O’Donnell’s resignation. Board President Scott Williams was absent.

Mr. O’Donnell said he was resigning his seat the day after a March 29 meeting in which he defended what were perceived to be by some as anti-Semitic comments toward Rabbi Barbara Symons and about her kippah or yarmulke at an intergovernmental meeting. Mr. O’Donnell initially defended his remarks, but later apologized after a phone conversation with Rabbi Symons.

Mr. O’Donnell resigned March 30, although he stated he had planned to resign as he was moving out of the district and the controversy was not the reason.

Advertise with us

“What Steve did was uncalled for, but I don’t want to let it go that Steve did nothing for our district,” said board member Valerie Warning, referring to his work on Gateway’s buildings and grounds committee. Ms. Warning also apologized again for Mr. O’Donnell’s comments.

“The heart of the issue is we should treat each other like good neighbors,” said board member John Ritter.

“My hope is that some good can come out of this,” Mr. Ritter said.

Board member Rick McIntyre said of the matter, “One of the most important steps is acknowledging you made a mistake.” He said the fact that Mr. O’Donnell did not acknowledge that right away and went on the attack was what was so disheartening.

Board Vice President Mary Beth Cirucci said the board is “deeply apologetic” to Rabbi Symons, the Monroeville Interfaith Ministerium and the community.

Advertise with us

She also read a letter that Mr. O’Donnell sent to the board in which he said, “At the end of the day I have taken myself to task and have concluded that my response to the rabbi’s letter was completely out of bounds,” and said his initial response had been “mean spirited.”

The board has 30 days to fill Mr. O’Donnell’s seat. His term was set to expire in December 2019.

Deana Carpenter, freelance writer: suburbanliving@post-gazette.com.