Gateway School Board member Steve O’Donnell has resigned after he was accused of making anti-Semitic remarks but says he is not stepping down because of the controversy and that he stands by his comments.

Mr. O’Donnell was accused at a Thursday night meeting of making disrespectful comments about Rabbi Barbara Symons, who leads Temple David and is president of the Monroeville Interfaith Ministerium.

A letter from members of the ministerium that was read at the meeting said that in addition to referring to Rabbi Symons as “Barb,”  after a Feb. 27 meeting, Mr. O’Donnell twice asked her, “Do you know you have a thing on your head?” referring to the kippah, or yarmulke, that she wears.

Mr. O’Donnell refused to apologize for his actions Thursday night, saying that Rabbi Symons should apologize to him and criticizing a separate letter she had sent about the incident.

Advertise with us

“The only thing I can assume from your letter with respect to that is that you judge yourself to be superior to me, perhaps it’s because you’re a Jew … or perhaps because you’ve attained a certain level in your organization,” Mr. O’Donnell said.

Friday morning he sent an email to the board and its solicitor saying he would resign, effective April 4. The board still has to vote on the resignation. He said he had already intended to resign and the action wasn’t prompted by the call for him to step down.

In a Facebook post, board member Rick McIntyre had called for Mr. O’Donnell’s resignation.

“I believe it’s in the best interest of the district and the board if Mr. O’Donnell excused himself from service as a board member,” Mr. McIntyre said in the post.

The ministerium letter also called for him to resign.

Advertise with us

“It is unclear why he chose not to respect Rabbi Barbara’s position as a leader in the community, but he did not offer her the same respect that he has given male clergy with whom he has been in conversation,” said the letter, which was read by Rev. David Morse, a retired Methodist pastor, at the meeting.

“If you find your actions that night not deserving of a sincere and public apology for your public anti-Semitic actions and comments, then there should be question of your fitness to serve as a school board director in a highly diverse community,” Rev. Morse read.

The members of the ministerium said they attended the Thursday school board meeting after the letter sent by Rabbi Symons to Mr. O’Donnell on March 13 never received a response.

In Rabbi Symons’ letter she wrote that after he made the comment about her kippah, his colleagues were silent.

“Hearing only silence from your colleagues, the deep discomfort of an anti-Semitic and disrespectful comment — not once but twice — led me, as quickly as I could to extricate myself from the conversation and leave the building,” wrote Rabbi Symons.

Advertise with us

Board members George Lapcevich and Scott Williams apologized for not speaking up that evening and for Mr. O’Donnell’s comments.

Mr. O’Donnell responded Thursday night by downplaying the incident.

“My attempt to interject a small amount of levity into a private conversation that I was a part of that took place in a public setting was nothing more than an attempt to bring a little levity to something that was otherwise a tense and difficult conversation,” Mr. O’Donnell said, calling his comments “lighthearted.”

He said when he read Rabbi Symons’ letter he found it to be “purposeful in its effort to misconstrue my comments. I found it self-centered. I found it arrogant and I found it close to libelous.”

“Who writes a letter and criticizes someone for not addressing them with their organizational title?” he said.

Advertise with us

Mr. O’Donnell said he has carried out the duties of an elected official very well and suggested that Rabbi Symons “tend to your flock and I’ll tend to mine.”

“You’re not going to get an apology from me. I deserve one from you,” he concluded.

Deana Carpenter, freelance writer: suburbanliving@post-gazette.com.