A former Gateway School District board member, who resigned last week amid accusations he made anti-Semitic comments to Monroeville Rabbi Barbara Symons at public meetings, has now apologized for his remarks, she said.

Steve O’Donnell initially defended his remarks at last week’s school board meeting but reversed course in a phone conversation, said Rabbi Symons.

“We spoke on Monday morning and he sounded very contrite, and we had in many ways a good conversation,” said Rabbi Symons of Temple David in Monroeville, who is also president of the Monroeville Interfaith Ministerium. “He apologized for what he said and that he was over the top. I think we still see things differently, but I certainly accepted his apology.”

She said he also told her he was sending a public letter of apology to his former school board colleagues.

Advertise with us

Mr. O’Donnell could not be reached for comment Thursday. The Pittsburgh Jewish Chronicle quoted him confirming his apology, saying that on reflection he realized he had erred.

At a public meeting several weeks ago, Mr. O’Donnell twice asked Rabbi Symons, “Do you know you have a thing on your head?” He was referring to her kippah, or yarmulke, worn by many Jews as a sign of reverence for God above. He also addressed her as “Barb,” not by her title as rabbi.

The ministerium, in a letter read at the school board’s March 29 meeting by Methodist minister David Morse, called for Mr. O’Donnell to resign. The letter said his comments were anti-Semitic and did not show her the same respect he had shown to male clergy.

At the board’s March 29 meeting, Mr. O’Donnell defended his comments and criticized a letter Rabbi Symons had sent on the incident, saying that perhaps “you judge yourself to be superior to me, perhaps it's because you're a Jew, or perhaps because you've attained a certain level in your organization.”

By the next day, he offered the board of his resignation, although saying the controversy was not the reason. But he also left messages with Rabbi Symons seeking to apologize.

Advertise with us

Rabbi Symons said the incident underscores the need for greater dialogue and understanding of the diverse population of the district’s communities, which are home to Muslim, Hindu, Jain and Sikh worship sites in addition to Jewish, Catholic and Protestant ones.

The ministerium is preparing an upcoming library program on the types of attire worn by observers of different faiths.

“We’re excited to bring some education, to be able to help one another respect one another,” she said.

Peter Smith: petersmith@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1416; Twitter @PG_PeterSmith.