Saying his crimes were about "good old-fashioned greed and lying" which left dozens of victims devastated, a federal judge on Wednesday sent Jack Hogan to prison for a decade for pulling the largest Ponzi scheme ever uncovered in Western Pennsylvania.

"Mr. Hogan," said U.S. District Judge Mark Hornak, "you really cleaned these people out."

Hogan, 78, former owner of Hogan & Associates, ripped off about 80 investors of $8.2 million.

The judge entered a forfeiture order for that amount but recognized that it's unlikely the victims will ever see any of it.

Advertise with us

Hogan waived indictment in April and pleaded guilty to multiple counts of mail fraud.

He had been in negotiations with prosecutors following an investigation by the FBI and postal inspectors that began in 2016. Confronted by agents, he confessed and spared the government the expense of grand jury proceedings.

Assistant U.S. Attorney Greg Melucci said Hogan sold whole life insurance policies to friends and family for many years from his Swissvale office.

But he also held himself out to be a financial planner when he was not one.

From 2002 on, he sold policies at exorbitant prices and encouraged clients to borrow against the accrued value of their policies, then invest in what he called a "promissory note" program that would give them a 10 percent return or higher.

Advertise with us

Mr. Melucci said the program amounted to a Ponzi scheme in which money from earlier investors was used to pay off more recent ones. Hogan, who earned up to $400,000 a year selling insurance, also used investor money to pay lenders who gave him loans for his real estate holdings in several states or to operate his business.

Numerous victims took the stand to describe what Hogan did to them. Most considered Hogan a friend and gave him money because they trusted him.

Janice Miller, 75, of Ross, said Hogan "wrecked my life." She met him in 2011 after her husband died. At his direction, she cashed in her late husband's stock, bought life insurance polices through Hogan and then borrowed against them to invest in his promissory notes, at one point re-financing her house. In the end, she lost $1.3 million and now lives on Social Security and a pension. She said she is two months from declaring bankruptcy.

"I was in a vulnerable position and he knew that," she said.

Others told similar tales of financial ruin. An East Liberty restaurant owner lost $40,000. A Greensburg electronics technician lost $118,000. A Swissvale special education teacher lost $34,500. The list went on and on.

Advertise with us

Mr. Melucci said Hogan capitalized on long-term relationships with clients, some dating back decades, in order to fleece them, then lived the high life with funds they were counting on for retirement.

When they tried to inquire about their money, Hogan made cursory payments in some cases but often was nowhere to be found.

Invoking the legend of Roman Emperor Nero, who famously fiddled while Rome burned, Mr. Melucci said "Jack played the fiddle while his clients burned."

Hogan made no excuses.

"It's very shameful and just a disgrace to be where I thought I would never be," he told the judge. "My clients trusted me and I abused that trust. If I had the money today to pay them back I would do it in an instant."

Advertise with us

His son, Josh Hogan, who runs an art studio in Bloomfield, and several friends said the man they knew would never hurt anyone and said they were having trouble understanding how he could have betrayed so many people.

Hogan's lawyer, Tina Miller, argued for leniency and pointed to other white-collar schemers who received lesser sentences than 10 years. She also said a decade in prison is essentially a life sentence for her client, who has a variety of health issues.

But Mr. Melucci had an answer for that.

"He deserves a life sentence," he said.

He said Hogan, in typical Ponzi fashion, put off his investors when they wanted their money, telling them he was having problems with borrowers and persuading clients to roll over their promissory notes to keep their money in his program for as long as possible.

Advertise with us

A lingering question is what happened to all the money. Hogan bought real estate in Arizona, Florida, Hawaii and elsewhere. He sold some, but other properties are encumbered with heavy debt or tax liens.

Judge Hornak suggested that the U.S. Justice Department's Asset Forfeiture Division take a close look at all the properties to see if any can be sold and turned over to U.S. control to at least pay some of the restitution.

The judge allowed Hogan to self-report to prison by March 7. He remains free on a $250,000 bond until then.

Torsten Ove: tove@post-gazette.com.