Raymond H. Sida, a house painter by trade, testified Tuesday that developers Ramesh and Vikas Jain tried to bribe him to take responsibility for a massive, illegal asbestos removal operation at the 135-acre former Westinghouse research property in Churchill that they own.

At the Allegheny County Health Department hearing, Mr. Sida said the Jains offered him $100,000, two houses — one for his mother — and a $5 an hour raise from his $19 an hour rate, if he would agree to take the blame for the illegal asbestos removal work, which was discovered by a Churchill Borough building inspector in February and halted by the health department in May.

They also offered his mother a car, Mr. Sida said.

The Jains have denied any involvement in the asbestos removal work, and Attorney Maurice Nernberg, who represents them, declined to comment on Mr. Sida’s testimony.

Advertise with us

“I don’t represent Mr. Sida. I’m not telling you anything else. I have no comment on what he said.”

The Allegheny County Health Department levied the largest asbestos related fines in its history — $1.47 million against the Jains and $451,400 against Mr. Sida — in June, alleging that more than 130,000 square feet of floor tile and pipe insulation containing asbestos were removed from two large buildings at the former George Westinghouse Research and Technology Park earlier this year.

In addition, according to the health department enforcement orders, the work was performed by untrained workers who were not provided any protective clothing or breathing masks and who didn’t post warning signs, allowed asbestos dust to be vented into the air outside the buildings, and did not dispose of the material in a landfill licensed to accept hazardous materials. Mr. Sida said the workers were all undocumented workers from Guatemala.

Mr. Sida, 51, who worked as a painter in New York City for more than 20 years before he was hired by the Jains five years ago, confirmed all of those allegations in his hearing testimony, but claimed he was only following orders issued either by Ramesh Jain or his son, Vikas, who, he said, told him the tile contained “safe” levels of asbestos.

“I had checked on the crew and saw they were cutting and ripping insulation from around the pipes. I knew that wasn’t right,” Mr. Sida said. “I asked RJ (Ramesh Jain) why they were doing that and he said, ‘Don’t worry about it.’ He told me to keep my mouth shut and not to tell anybody about the asbestos removal.”

Advertise with us

When he asked more questions he was pulled off of the Churchill job and sent to work at another Jain property in Beckley, W.Va. After three days there he was told the Churchill job had been shut down, and Vikas Jain called him and told him to come back to Pittsburgh.

“I asked to what purpose. He said, ‘To take the blame,’ ” Mr. Sida testified. “I said no and he got very angry. He promised the world — money, house, a car. ‘We’ll pay you if you take the blame. Please, my father can’t go through this.’ ”

Mr. Sida denied he was the owner of Pintura Construction, LLC, the company that employed the asbestos removal workers, as the original health department enforcement order claimed, saying that the Jains created the company and forged his signature on bank documents and corporate papers.

“This is orchestrated fraud by the Jains perpetrated on a painter who was an hourly employee for five years,” Ken Hardin, Mr. Sida’s attorney, said in an opening statement at the hearing, which was held to determine Mr. Sida’s ability to pay the fine. The Jains went through a similar hearing on their ability to pay their fine in August, but the hearing was closed to the public and news media at their request.

Jason Willis, assistant solicitor for the health department’s air quality division, said the department had determined Mr. Sida “would not have the ability to pay,” and agreed to waive that issue.

Advertise with us

ACHD hearing Officer Max Slater delayed ruling on a motion by Mr. Hardin to dismiss the case and have the enforcement order set aside, pending testimony from two more witnesses, including Brad Sommer, an attorney hired by the Jains to represent Mr. Sida. Mr. Slater continued the hearing but set no date for its resumption.

The health department is still seeking information about where the asbestos-containing material was taken.

“The department is trying to ascertain the truth the best we can and find out what happened to the asbestos that was removed,” Mr. Willis said.

Mr. Sida testified the tile and pipe insulation was put into plastic bags and taken by pickup truck to dumpsters in front of the workers’ residence, another Jains-owned property about 2 miles from the Westinghouse property. The dumpsters were removed when filled and replaced with an empty one.

Mr. Sida also said the material was taken by truck to the Motel 6 on Banksville Road in Banksville, another Jains-owned property, where it was “put in a dumpster, or sometimes when the dumpster was full, behind the building.”

Advertise with us

Shannon Sandberg, a health department air quality engineer who attended the hearing, said the department is trying to determine where the asbestos material was landfilled but tracking isn’t required on dumpsters that are supposed to contain only non-hazardous materials.

Sampling at the redevelopment project work site by the ACHD found the tile and pipe insulation to contain up to 65 percent amosite asbestos, which studies have found to cause cancer.

Don Hopey: dhopey@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1983, or on Twitter @donhopey.