A development firm is seeking to reduce fines of almost $2 million levied for illegal removal and disposal of tons of asbestos at the 135-acre former Westinghouse research property in Churchill.

According to administrative orders filed by the Allegheny County Health Department, workers on the project were not provided with protective clothing or breathing masks when grinding and handling the cancer-causing asbestos floor tile and pipe insulation.

And no precautions were were taken to prevent asbestos dust from becoming airborne outside two large buildings on the former George Westinghouse Research and Technology Park corporate campus and causing a potential public health problem.

In addition, the more than 130,000 square feet of asbestos containing tile and pipe insulation material was not disposed of in an approved landfill, and so may have been dumped illegally, according to the health department.

Advertise with us

According to an enforcement order, issued June 2, Ramesh Jain and his son, Vikas Jain, owners of Churchill Community Development LP, and Paradigm Consultants LLC, were fined $1.47 million for multiple violations of the county’s asbestos removal regulations.

A separate enforcement order, also dated June 2, levies fines totaling $451,400 against Pintura Construction LLC, and Ramon Perez, who were working for the Vains,  for violations of the asbestos regulations.

Investigators from the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency have also been to Pittsburgh “a couple of times, building a case” on the asbestos issue, said Jim Kelly, ACHD deputy director.

A hearing was held at the ACHD offices Downtown on Monday to hear an appeal by the Jains for a reduction of the penalties, which together are the biggest ever sought by the health department in an asbestos case.

The Jains asked that the hearing be closed to the public and press, and the health department granted that request, said Mr. Kelly.

Advertise with us

“There has been no resolution. We need additional information,” said Jason Willis, assistant solicitor for the health department’s air quality division.“ A second hearing will be held, but has not yet been scheduled.”

Work on much of the multi-million dollar redevelopment project, first known as “Shoppes at Pittsburgh Studios,” and then “Churchill Crossings,” was shut down in May. And three main buildings, listed as “801, 501 and 401,” remain “locked down,” Mr. Willis said.

The project owners must apply for and receive the required asbestos removal permits and perform abatement and cleanup work in buildings 401 and 501 before work on the project can restart, he said. The redevelopment plan would convert the former Westinghouse research facility into film studios, retail shops, and office space.

The asbestos removal work was first discovered Feb. 28 by Shawn Jacobs, a certified building inspector for Churchill Borough, who saw three men in Building 501, removing suspected asbestos-containing floor tiles with grinder machines and disposing of the material in plastic garbage bags. The order states that “witnesses observed dust plumes from bags removed from buildings and thrown into a pickup truck.”

County air quality inspectors were called to the site and took samples of the material which was found to contain up to 65 percent amosite asbestos, which has been found to cause cancer. On Mar. 1, Mr. Willis issued a verbal order prohibiting additional asbestos removal and a day later issued a written order mandating cleanup of the site.

Advertise with us

A week later, county inspectors also found similar asbestos-containing floor tiles had been removed from Building 401.

“The Jains, Churchill and Paradigm, in allowing the removal of asbestos containing material from Buildings #401 and #501 without the necessary permits, safety equipment, signage, or proper notification to the department that any abatement was taking place, allowed workers to be exposed to significant quantities of friable asbestos,” the order states. “Such activity placed Pintura’s workers, and those exposed to asbestos fibers escaping the buildings, at risk of asbestos related illnesses.”

The June enforcement order notes that the health department was contacted by an unnamed attorney representing Churchill Community Development and the Jains on March 13, who said Churchill had contracted with Pintura to “clean” Building 50, but “it was their position that the asbestos was removed by the previous owner.”

Attorney Maurice Nernberg, who represented the Jains at the Monday hearing, did not return calls requesting comment Tuesday.

An April 7 response to the March 2 emergency order, filed on behalf of the Jains and their businesses, admitted grinding machines were present at the property but had not been used, and stated, “Appellants are not aware of any removal of asbestos containing material and did not authorize any removal.”

Advertise with us

The Jains received grants totaling $3.5 million from the state, but have not used any of that money, according to state Sen. Jay Costa, D-Forest Hills, who has supported the redevelopment project and still thinks it can be a valuable asset to Churchill and surrounding communities.

“There are no plans to remove the funding, nor would I recommend it,” Mr. Costa said. “It’s a good project. The state felt that way. And, depending on the outcome of the asbestos issue, the grants can always be switched to new developers of the site.

“I am concerned about the project being on hold. I hope we can get through this sooner rather than later and we can get the ball rolling again.”

Don Hopey: dhopey@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1983, or on Twitter @donhopey