The defense attorney for a man convicted of kidnapping his own daughter argued Tuesday that he never should have been charged with that count and that the resulting sentence that he received, 8 to 22 years, is excessive.

The three-judge panel of the Pennsylvania Superior Court that heard the case of Tex Ortiz, noted that the trial judge was recently chastised by the court for meting out overly harsh penalties.

Ortiz, 34, was found guilty by a jury in May 2015 of kidnapping and interference with custody of children. According to investigators, Ortiz was raising his 2-year-old daughter after her mother died unexpectedly in October 2014. Although the girl’s maternal grandparents saw her often, Ortiz retained custody, and at one point, even went to family court to ensure that was the case. There he was told he did not need to take any action.

However, by December 2014, the maternal grandparents wanted custody and filed an emergency petition. They were responsible for providing Ortiz notice for a hearing, but he claims he never received it. A hearing was held Dec. 19 without Ortiz present. The grandparents were awarded interim custody of the child. A few days later, after receiving a phone call and text message purporting to be a Penn Hills police officer, Ortiz took the girl and fled. They were found in Altoona two weeks later.

Advertise with us

Ortiz raised several issues on appeal, including sufficiency of the evidence for the kidnapping count, arguing that kidnapping requires that he removed the child “in order to facilitate the commission of any felony or flight.”

Defense attorney Victoria Vidt argued to the panel that her client taking his daughter to Altoona was not done to facilitate a felony or flight, and there was no malicious intent.

The legislative intent for kidnapping, she wrote in her brief, was “meant to apply to acts of political terrorism, vengeful or sadistic abductions, with a high degree of danger to the victim. This is not the case here.”

Instead, he took his daughter because he feared for her safety, the defense said, and she was returned unharmed.

To the prosecution’s argument that the interference with custody charge is the requisite felony for kidnapping, Ms. Vidt said that has never been done before. Further, she argued that the grading of interference can be a misdemeanor if it is a parent who takes the child, which means kidnapping does not fit.

Advertise with us

Ortiz is asking for the kidnapping count to be vacated.

“Shouldn’t we go cautiously in terms of calling parents who are exercising custody rights ‘kidnappers?’ ” Superior Court Judge John T. Bender asked the prosecution during argument. “There’s enough with the other charge.”

Assistant District Attorney Rebecca Good McBride, who argued the case for the commonwealth, called it “a difficult case,” and said she wished she were in the room when the prosecution’s charging decisions were made.

The panel then turned its attention to Ortiz’s sentence.

Ms. Vidt wrote in her brief that the penalties imposed by Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Donna Jo McDaniel — 2 to 4 years in prison for interference and 6 to 18 years for kidnapping to be served consecutively — were “manifestly excessive and an abuse of the trial court’s discretion.

Advertise with us

She noted that during a motion hearing in Ortiz’s case — prior to his being found guilty — that Judge McDaniel said, in response to a prosecution motion for a protective order prohibiting contact between Ortiz and his daughter, “I desire him not to have a relationship [with his daughter].”

Ms. Vidt said in her brief that, in her sentence, Judge McDaniel “adopted a stance more akin to retribution or vindictiveness.”

During oral argument, Ms. Vidt did not address the issue of the sentence, but the panel of judges, including Judge Bender, who wrote recent opinions about Judge McDaniel and a “possible emerging pattern” from her of excessive punishment in sex assault cases, did. They raised the issue with the commonwealth’s attorney.

“I know your concerns about this particular sentencing court,” Ms. McBride said.

“This is the reason the commonwealth shouldn’t pile on,” Judge Bender said.

Advertise with us

President Judge Susan Peikes Gantman said she did not believe Oritz having his daughter for two weeks is an “exorbitant amount of time.”

“This is the child of this person,” Judge Bender added. “He takes his child for two weeks and gets eight to 22 years?”

Ms. McBride could not answer, other than to repeat, “it is a very difficult case.”

Paula Reed Ward: pward@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2620 or on Twitter: @PaulaReedWard.