Defense attorneys for two men accused of killing six people at a Wilkinsburg cookout last year have called into question two jail-house informants cooperating in the case against their clients.

Both of the men, Kendall Mikell, identified in the criminal complaint as Witness No. 1, and Frederick Collins, identified as Witness No. 2, have cooperated with prosecutors multiple times in the past.

Mikell, 29, has testified in two other homicide cases and was listed as a possible witness in a third — although the prosecutor on that case chose not to call him, telling the court he found him to be not credible. And Collins told police he has testified in two homicide trials and cooperated in at least two others.

Cheron Shelton Following the filing of today’s charges, updated mug shots were taken of Robert Thomas and Cheron Shelton.

Cheron Shelton

Advertise with us
Robert Thomas Following the filing of today’s charges, updated mug shots were taken of Robert Thomas and Cheron Shelton. They are attached for your use and reference as many of you had requested them.

Robert Thomas

The information on the informants is contained in motions filed by the attorneys for Cheron Shelton, 30, of Lincoln-Lemington, and Robert Thomas, 28, of Homewood. They are accused of killing Jerry Michael Shelton, 35, Brittany Powell, 27, and Chanetta Powell, 25, and their cousins Tina Shelton, 37, and Shada Mahone, 26, on March 9 at a cookout on Franklin Avenue. Chanetta Powell was eight months pregnant.

Randall McKinney, who represents Shelton, and Casey White, who represents Thomas, have filed a variety of motions in the case, seeking additional discovery information specifically regarding Collins and Mikell, and what, if any promises or offers have been made to them for their cooperation in the case.

The criminal complaint dedicated 3½ pages of information to the informants, who told homicide investigators that both Thomas and Shelton told them separately of their involvement in the Wilkinsburg shootings while they were housed together at the jail.

Specifically, Mikell told police that Thomas told him he urinated in a garage in an alley near the shooting scene, and that he worried investigators would be able to obtain his DNA there. The affidavit noted there was a garage similar to what Mikell said Thomas described near the crime scene.

Advertise with us

Collins told police that Shelton told him they targeted Lamont Powell, who was injured but not killed in the shooting, because they believed he’d been involved in an earlier homicide of Calvin Doswell, Shelton told Collins, the affidavit said, that he had an assault rifle that night, while Thomas had a handgun. Mikell provided investigators that same information, as well.

The affidavit noted, too, that Mikell’s information that Thomas told him they were stopped by police early on the morning after the shooting is confirmed by Penn Hills police, who said there was a field contact with Shelton at 2:18 a.m. Because there were no active warrants for him, though, they let him go.

A woman reacts at the scene of a mass shooting in March in Wilkinsburg. (Michael Henninger / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

According to various court records, Mikell has cooperated in at least three other homicide cases in recent years in Allegheny County. He testified in the jury trial of Samuel Mitchell in August before Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Edward J. Borkowski. Mitchell was found not guilty.

Mikell is also a witness in a still-pending homicide case against Rodney Howard.

In that case, defense attorney James Wymard asked that Mikell’s testimony be suppressed -—both because the man was acting as an agent of the state by gathering information from Howard, and because, Mr. Wymard argued, Allegheny County Chief Trial Deputy District Attorney Dan Fitzsimmons had found Mikell to be not credible in another homicide case against Henry Little-Proctor. Mr. Fitzsimmons chose not to call Mikell in that case. Little-Proctor and his co-defendant, Rashawn Walker, were found not guilty of killing Susan Sidney.

Advertise with us

Mr. Wymard, who won the suppression motion — now on appeal to the state Superior Court — said that Mikell makes it sound like every inmate at the jail confesses to him.

“Like they’re going to talk to him?” Mr. Wymard said. “It’s utterly ridiculous.”

In an opinion filed in the Howard case, Common Pleas Judge Randal B. Todd said he was suppressing Mikell’s statements against the defendant because he found him to have been working as an agent of the state when he gathered the information. Mikell had met with investigators multiple times, and received instructions from them to “find out what he could about other criminal matters.” Mikell also admitted that at one meeting, it was clear that he knew Howard was represented by an attorney. Mr. Wymard argued that Mikell was acting as an agent of the prosecution by trying to get Howard to provide incriminating information against himself.

Judge Todd agreed, finding that there was an implied agreement between the prosecution and Mikell that he would receive sentencing consideration on his own federal charges in exchange for his cooperation.

“The fact that Mikell may not have been ‘guaranteed’ a recommendation for sentence reduction does not negate the evidence of an implied agreement. On the contrary, the fact that the possibility of some future consideration might be forthcoming would be a significant inducement for Mikell to continue to provide information regarding various inmates.”

Advertise with us

At the time of the discussions with investigators regarding the Howard case, Mikell was charged in federal court with conspiracy to possess a firearm in furtherance of a drug trafficking crime. His sentencing guidelines in that case called for a minimum of seven years in prison.

Instead, he was ordered to serve one year and one day to run concurrently with a five- to 10-year prison term for robbery and aggravated assault he was already facing in state court.

Paula Reed Ward: pward@post-gazette, 412-263-2620 or on Twitter: @PaulaReedWard.