The Allegheny County District Attorney’s office on Tuesday informed lawyers for two men charged in the mass slaying of five adults and an unborn child in Wilkinsburg last year that they will not use one of two jailhouse informants at trial.
In a letter to attorneys representing Cheron Shelton and Robert Thomas, the prosecution said it will not call Frederick Collins as a witness.
“After assessing the case, Mr. Collins’ role in it and his current status, the commonwealth has decided that it will not be using Mr. Collins’ testimony in the above prosecution,” according to the letter, signed by Deputy District Attorney Kevin Chernosky and assistant district attorney Lisa Pellegrini.
Collins, who was housed in the Allegheny County Jail with Shelton and Thomas in April 2016, told police that Shelton told him they targeted Lamont Powell, who was injured but not killed in the shooting, because they believed he had been involved in the Oct. 15, 2013, homicide of Calvin Doswell in Lincoln-Lemington. Shelton told Collins, the affidavit said, that he used an assault rifle that night, while Thomas had a handgun.
But last month, Collins, who has a lengthy criminal record, was charged with threatening the Common Pleas judge presiding over his case. He was to be sentenced on 2015 charges of intimidating a witness, retaliation against a prosecutor, aggravated assault and related counts.
As his hearing began, Collins stood up and began screaming profanities at Judge Donna Jo McDaniel.
Read More
After that incident, attorneys for Shelton and Thomas questioned whether the DA’s office would use Collins in the case. Information provided by Collins and another jailhouse informant, Kendall Mikell, was prominently featured in the affidavit of probable cause supporting the arrests of Shelton and Thomas in the Wilkinsburg mass shooting.
Killed during the March 9, 2016, attack were Chanetta Powell, 25, who was eight months pregnant; Jerry Shelton, 35; Tina Shelton, 37; Brittany Powell, 27; and Shada Mahone, 26.
The prosecutors’ letter to defense counsel said no decision has yet been made on whether they will use Mikell at trial.
However, they did say that because Collins will no longer be used, that there will be no need to fight in court over issues of discovery — evidence gathered prior to trial — related to Collins.
But attorney Randall McKinney, who represents Shelton, said that’s not the case.
“The applications for search warrants contained information from this now non-usable confidential informant,” Mr. McKinney said. “It’s arguable that any information obtained from this corrupted source is fruit of the poisonous tree and should be inadmissible.”
According to Mr. McKinney, any evidence gathered as a result of information provided by Collins would be inadmissible.
Mr. McKinney plans to file a motion on the issue this week.
In the meantime, Judge David R. Cashman said he will rule later this month whether charges from a 2013 drug and gun arrest against Shelton, Thomas and another defendant ought to be thrown out. The charges were withdrawn twice before but refiled during the investigation into the Wilkinsburg slaying.
Defense attorneys argue that the 2013 charges would never have been refiled were it not for the slayings last year, and that the prosecution has failed to try the case within the 365-day period required by law.
Paula Reed Ward: pward@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2620 or on Twitter: @PaulaReedWard.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.