Fearful that a key witness with a history of courtroom outbursts might hurt them at trial, prosecutors are weighing whether to let the jailhouse informant testify against two men charged with a mass shooting last year in Wilkinsburg.
Frederick Collins, who is identified as Witness No. 2 in the affidavit of probable cause against Cheron Shelton and Robert Thomas, went on a profanity-laced tirade in court last month, prompting the Allegheny County District Attorney’s office to review whether he could be a reliable witness in their case involving the March 9, 2016 slayings of five adults and an unborn child on Franklin Avenue.
Collins, 36, was charged Monday with terroristic threats and retaliation against a judicial officer for his outburst on April 26 before Common Pleas Judge Donna Jo McDaniel.
He was to be sentenced that afternoon on charges stemming from 2015, including intimidating a witness, retaliation against a prosecutor or judicial official, aggravated assault, terroristic threats, institutional vandalism, resisting arrest and harassment.
Those charges stemmed from another court outburst he had before a district judge in West Mifflin, where he was to have a hearing Oct. 1 for a domestic dispute.
As the hearing began, according to the criminal complaint, Collins stood up and began screaming. The judge ordered that he be removed. Collins threatened to kill the victim in his case on the way out of the building and officers then placed him in handcuffs and put him in the back of a patrol car.
Read More
Collins became enraged, kicked the windows and bars in the car, got his hand out of one of the cuffs and continued to disobey officers. Several times he used his fingers to pantomime pulling the trigger of a gun. He was shocked with a Taser four times, leading him to defecate. Police said he then smeared his feces in their patrol car. As District Judge Richard Olasz left the building, Collins threatened to kill him, too.
Collins pleaded no contest in that case in October, but at the hearing before Judge McDaniel on April 26, he asked to withdraw his plea. She refused his request.
According to the new criminal complaint filed by the Allegheny County Sheriff’s Office, Collins launched into a tirade, telling Judge McDaniel that if she sentenced him he would “blow your...face off.” He then added that he would hurt her grandchildren, too.
Collins continued, the complaint said, “I don’t give a [expletive] about her being no judge. Do you not understand that?”
Judge McDaniel had Collins removed from the courtroom and sentenced him to six to 12 years in prison.
At a status conference in the Wilkinsburg case on Friday, Thomas’ defense attorney, Casey White, raised questions about Collins’ status as a witness against his client, arguing that he is unreliable based on his behavior before Judge McDaniel, as well as multiple trips to the jail’s mental health unit.
Common Pleas Judge David R. Cashman told Mr. White those are questions of credibility, which must be decided by a jury.
Collins has a lengthy criminal record dating back to 1999, and Mr. White said that his nickname in the Allegheny County Jail is “Psycho.”
Assistant District Attorney Kevin Chernosky said at that hearing that the prosecution team is discussing whether it will continue to pursue using Collins as a witness in the case and should make a decision this week.
In the criminal complaint against Shelton and Thomas, Collins told officers that Shelton told him at the jail that the attackers were targeting Lamont Powell, who was injured but not killed in the Wilkinsburg shooting because they believed he had been involved in the homicide of Calvin Doswell. Shelton also told Collins that he had an assault rifle that night, while Thomas had a handgun, the affidavit said.
A large part of the criminal complaint against Shelton and Thomas was based on information provided by Collins and another jailhouse informant. Attorneys for the defendants have called the case largely circumstantial.
Police said Shelton and Thomas received a call from someone on March 9 alerting them to a Facebook post showing Powell at the Franklin Avenue barbecue.
Detectives believe Thomas and Shelton then drove to the house, where Thomas opened fire with a handgun to herd the crowd toward the home’s back porch while Shelton shot them with an assault rifle at close range.
Killed were Chanetta Powell, 25, who was eight months pregnant; Jerry Shelton, 35; Tina Shelton, 37; Brittany Powell, 27; and Shada Mahone, 26.
Paula Reed Ward: pward@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2620 or on Twitter: @PaulaReedWard.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.