A man accused of setting a 1995 blaze that killed three Pittsburgh firefighters will be released from jail -— after spending 20 years in custody -— while he awaits trial in federal court.

But that was not the outcome that Gregory Brown Jr. and his defense counsel hoped for Wednesday. They wanted Mr. Brown, 39, to remain in state court -— and therefore in jail — because they believe his criminal case should be heard in Allegheny County Common Pleas Court, not in U.S. District Court.

“They didn’t like the results they were getting, so they want to run to another court,” said defense attorney Dave Fawcett. “The appearance of injustice is overwhelming.”

Mr. Brown, who was convicted in 1997 of three counts of second-degree murder and arson as a result of the fire on Bricelyn Street in East Hills won the right to a retrial in 2014 after his attorneys presented evidence of prosecutorial misconduct at his first trial — specifically that a federal Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives agent on the case had offered reward money to witnesses, who then lied on the stand about the arrangement.

Advertise with us

The District Attorney’s office appealed the decision of Common Pleas Judge Joseph K. Williams III, but the state Superior Court affirmed him, and the state Supreme Court refused to take the case.

In October 2015, prosecutors asked Judge Williams to recuse himself, accusing him of bias and a conflict of interest.

Judge Williams refused, and the DA’s office again appealed. Superior Court denied that request in August, and the case was scheduled to go to trial before Judge Williams in January.

But on Nov. 1 a federal grand jury indicted Mr. Brown on one count of malicious destruction of property by fire resulting in death, and three days later, the DA’s office filed a motion to withdraw the charges against him, citing the federal indictment. Judge Williams held a hearing on the request to withdraw charges Wednesday.

Deputy District Attorney Rebecca Walker told the court that state and federal prosecutors had worked together on the case from the outset and there would not be a delay Mr. Brown’s trial. Instead, she said, it will provide a better forum for the prosecution. When the case was originally tried in 1997, Mr. Brown faced a sentence of mandatory life without parole if convicted of second-degree murder. Under a recent change in the law, however, because Mr. Brown was a juvenile at the time of the fire, were he convicted, he would at some point become eligible for parole.

Advertise with us

Ms. Walker also said that trying the case in federal court would allow the prosecution to present evidence of motive that would be precluded in state court, and that agents with the federal Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives agency would have fought to quash subpoenas requiring them to testify in state court.

“That would greatly hinder our ability to try the case,” Ms. Walker said.

Mr. Brown's defense team objected to the motion to withdraw the state case, arguing that prosecutors were forum shopping because they didn’t like the results from Judge Williams.

“They want to teach us a lesson,” said Mr. Fawcett. “‘Hey, if you hold us accountable, there’s going to be hell to pay.’”

Judge Williams said that while there was merit in the defense position, the prosecution’s request to withdraw the state case was reasonable. He granted the motion.

Advertise with us

The judge called the initial reasons stated by the prosecution for withdrawing the case “shallow.” He took umbrage at a statement by U.S. Attorney David J. Hickton in announcing the federal indictment that “substantial questions have been raised which undermine confidence in a retrial in state court.”

Judge Williams noted that his findings had been upheld throughout the state appellate courts.

Mike Manko, a spokesman for the DA’s office, said following the hearing that the community continues to mourn the three firefighters, Thomas Brooks, 42; Patricia Conroy, 43; and Marc Kolenda, 27, two decades later.

“The defendant accused of these murders has been granted a new trial and must again be given the presumption of innocence,” Mr. Manko said. “It's important to note that the issues raised during the appeal involved information that was known to all parties at the time of the original trial -- including through public pronouncements. "

Mr. Brown made his initial appearance in federal court Monday before U.S. Magistrate Judge Lisa Pupo Lenihan. She granted him a $10,000 unsecured bond and ordered that he be placed in the custody of his stepfather, Ronald Buckner, when he is released on the federal bond.

Advertise with us

The case as been assigned to U.S. District Judge David S. Cercone, who presided over the trial in state court when he was a judge on the Common Pleas bench.

Paula Reed Ward: pward@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2620 or on Twitter: @PaulaReedWard.