In October 1942, an Altoona teenager dropped out of high school to enlist in the Marines. It was less than a year after the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor, and he was far from alone: “258 More Volunteer Here for Chance to Chase Axis,” a Pittsburgh Press headline said in announcing his and fellow recruits’ names.

On Nov. 20, 1943, Pfc. Nicholas J. Cancilla made the ultimate sacrifice in that pursuit. He was killed on the first day of the ferocious Battle of Tarawa, a crucial early fight for Allied control of the Pacific. He was 18.

And for nearly seven decades, his remains lay buried on what is now the island nation of Kiribati, 7,000 miles from home.

Now, thanks to the work of private researchers and a Defense Department analysis, Pfc. Cancilla’s remains will be returned to Altoona, where he will be memorialized at a funeral Mass on Monday at his childhood parish, Our Lady of Mount Carmel Catholic Church.

Advertise with us

He will be buried next to his Italian-immigrant parents in Calvary Cemetery and near the grave of his namesake and nephew — who was himself killed in the Vietnam War in 1969.

Even after so much time, repatriating those killed and long-missing during World War II is important for families, said Staff Sgt. Kristen Duus, public affairs representative of the Defense POW/​MIA Accounting Agency, which announced the identification of Pfc. Cancilla’s remains Monday.

“It still provides that closure that can they finally bring them home and bury them,” she said.

Nicholas John Cancilla was born Dec. 6, 1924, the second son of Frank and Maria Cancilla.

His elder brother, the late Frank Cancilla Jr., once described Nicholas as “a jolly fellow (who) didn’t have a care,” according to his obituary, provided by Santella Funeral Home in Altoona. He kept busy with football, wrestling and bugling with the American Legion Junior Drum Corps, was popular with girls and reguarly attended Mass at Mt. Carmel.

Advertise with us

He enlisted despite his parents’ objections to his dropping out of school. He was assigned to the Second Marine Division in the Pacific and was soon preparing for battle alongside veterans of recent Pacific campaigns at Tulagi and Guadalcanal.

His parents received a letter Nov. 12, 1943, saying his unit was on the move but not to worry. The Marines met ferocious resistance from Japanese who had heavily fortified the island of Betio in the Tarawa Atoll.

Pfc. Cancilla was among about 1,000 U.S. servicemen killed in the three-day assault. U.S. troops ultimately prevailed, gaining a strategic base from which to press the campaign toward Japan.

Pfc. Cancilla’s parents ultimately learned of his death, and he was mourned at a solemn Mass.

Although the remains many of those slain at Tarawa have been repatriated, the location of some had remained unknown.

Advertise with us

A private organization, History Flight Inc., has worked for years to find burial sites and took out newspaper ads asking local residents for any leads. A resident reported finding human remains while digging in his yard, and after History Flight workers inspected the site in 2011, they alerted the Defense Department, which excavated the remains of three Marines there in 2012.

Frank Cancilla Jr. submitted a DNA sample, enabling investigators to confirm his brother’s identity. But Frank Cancilla, himself a Navy veteran of World War II, did not live to see his brother’s homecoming. He died Nov. 16, 2015 at age 93. He and his wife, Mary, had named their son for Nicholas. He was killed in action in the Vietnam War.

The Rev. Frank Scornaienchi, pastor of Mt. Carmel Church, said that while Frank Cancilla didn’t speak in detail of his family’s military experiences, they were deeply important to him.

“I know every Veteran’s Day, Frank would be very pleased because we would try to get a bulletin cover that had something to with the veterans and have a prayer for veterans,” he said.

Peter Smith: petersmith@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1416.

; Twitter @PG_PeterSmith.