The year-long controversy regarding Phil Shar, the West Jefferson Hills School District’s girls varsity basketball coach, was reignited Tuesday night as the school board decided on a split vote to open the position and advertise for applicants.

Anyone may apply, including Mr. Shar, whose one-year contract expired in mid-February following the basketball season.

“It’s an opportunity for us to see what’s out there. We are trying to find a resolution to this ongoing situation,” board president Brian Fernandes said after Tuesday’s meeting.

The board vote was 5-4: Mr. Fernandes and board members Dave Dominick, Suzanne Downer, Kerri Gonot and Darlene Schreiber voted to open the position.

Advertise with us

For months, parents and their daughters complained to the board about bullying, belittling and the humiliating of players by Mr. Shar, resulting in 10 girls quitting the team. They hoped he would be dismissed or have a prior suspension reinstated, after which the girls planned to rejoin the team.

Mr. Shar had his supporters — girls who chose to remain with the team and their parents, with the girls lauding him as a fine coach dedicated to helping them become better players.

In December, the board, with five newly elected members, issued a one-sentence statement that Mr. Shar could continue, but that there would be “expectations” for the remainder of the season.

Tuesday night, Mr. Fernandes refused to say whether Mr. Shar met the board’s expectations, stating it was a “personnel issue.”

Mr. Shar was hired as coach two years ago at $8,800 per year. The team had two sectional wins and 10 losses this past season, finishing last. None of the 10 girls who quit the team ever rejoined.

The board hopes to sign a coach before the start of the summer league in June.