West Jefferson Hills school officials have outlined a list of “expectations” for the high school girls basketball coach following months of contentious meetings in which some team members sharply criticized his treatment of them and called for his ouster.

The school board announced Dec. 10, after a lengthy closed-door meeting days before, that it would keep Phil Shar on as coach.

The decision was a disappointment for 10 former players and their parents, who were hoping Mr. Shar would be dismissed or have a prior suspension reinstated, after which the girls planned to rejoin the team.

The girls have complained about what they described as Mr. Shar’s verbal abuse and humiliation of team members.

Advertise with us

Others on the team, however, lauded Mr. Shar as a fine coach who’s dedicated to helping them become better players.

Board members declined to say what the district’s expectations are for the coach, although new school board President Brian Fernandes said, “We have listened to all stakeholders involved in this very complicated, sensitive issue.”

Parent Mike Mascaro of Jefferson Hills said he admired the 10 girls.

“They took a stand for something they really believe in, and not just for their own benefit but for the girls to come. At great personal sacrifice, the girls gave up something they really love,” he said of playing basketball.

Superintendent Michael Panza said the 10 girls who chose not to play for Mr. Shar may rejoin the team anytime before the playoffs, according to WPIAL regulations.

Advertise with us

​“​I am happy, and ​I​ am very happy with my team​, both the varsity and the junior varsity teams,” Mr. Shar said when contacted Tuesday. ​“We think we’re going to have a great season.”

​“T​he girls on my team and the parents were very supportive during this situation​,” he said. “I really appreciate the 10 girls and the 10 sets of parents​,​ they did a great job​.”

Later, he added, “Every day during practice, the false accusations about me pop up. My current players cannot stop laughing. My current players, my assistant Craig D’Alessandro and me still haven’t figured out why this situation occurred.”

He said the girls started practice Nov. 17 and none have missed a practice. About 18 regular games remain in the regular season.

Jeff and Christa Lynch of Jefferson Hills, whose daughter Alanna, 14, plays on the team, were pleased that Mr. Shar will coach.

Advertise with us

“I did not feel there was any outside evidence to support the claims against the coach — not complaints from WPIAL or PIAA, or from other school officials, or our school officials, or a competing school,” Mr. Lynch said.

In September, the board suspended Mr. Shar with pay pending an investigation. A month later, he was reinstated with a 5-4 board vote, an action met with outrage, tears and disbelief by parents and players in attendance at the meeting.

In November, the girls who refused to play basketball with Mr. Shar as coach reiterated their complaints while their parents asked that his suspension be reinstated. Eight team members appeared in support of him.

Board member Anna Louise Lilley voted in September to suspend Mr. Shar and against reinstating him as coach in October.

“We’re going to keep an eye on him that he follows through like a coach,” she said.

Advertise with us

Mr. Shar was hired two years ago at $8,900 per year to coach the girls. When his contract expires at the end of the year, he will be reviewed as are all coaching positions, Mr. Panza said.

Ms. Lilley added, “I'm telling the girls to be positive and go back and show him he can’t take something — the love of basketball — away from them.”

Staff writer Janice Crompton contributed. Margaret Smykla, freelance writer: suburbanliving@post-gazette.com.