Phil Shar will continue as the high school girls basketball coach in the West Jefferson Hills School District for the foreseeable future.

That was the decision of the school board last night as expressed in a one-sentence prepared statement from new board President Brian Fernandes: “A letter will be issued to Mr. Shar containing the expectations of the board for the remainder of the season.”

As to what those expectations are, he said after the meeting, “I’m not ready to outline that yet.”

Following months of parents and their daughters expressing complaints at board meetings of bullying, belittling, and humiliating players by Mr. Shar, the outcome came in a reconvened meeting from Tuesday that lasted less than five minutes.

Advertise with us

The decision was a bitter disappointment for the 10 girls and their parents who were hoping he would be dismissed or have a prior suspension reinstated, after which the girls planned to rejoin the team.

“I admire the girls,” said parent Mike Mascaro of Jefferson Hills after the meeting.

“They took a stand for something they really believe in, and not just for their own benefit but for the girls to come,” he said.

Mr. Shar had supporters in the girls who chose to remain with the team and their parents, with the girls lauding him as a fine coach dedicated to helping them become better players.

Jeff and Christa Lynch of Jefferson Hills, who skipped Thursday night’s basketball game for the first time to attend the meeting, were happy with the board’s decision.

Advertise with us

“I did not feel there was any outside evidence to support the claims against the coach,” Mr. Lynch said.

Mr. Shar was hired two years ago at $8,900 per year to coach the girls basketball team. When his one-year contract expires, he will be reviewed as are all coaching positions, Superintendent Michael Panza said.

He also said the 10 girls who refused to play for Mr. Shar may rejoin the team , if they choose, any time before the playoffs, according to WPIAL regulations.