Thomas Jefferson High School girls basketball coach Phil Shar was reinstated Tuesday, after being suspended last month, but it remains unclear as to whether there will be a varsity girls team when practice begins on Nov. 16.

Parents of team members say that at least 10 girls will not play under Mr. Shar because they and their daughters find his coaching style to be negative and demeaning.

The parents are now equally as frustrated with the West Jefferson Hills school board, which voted 5-4 to reinstate Mr. Shar following a surprise motion that was not on the printed agenda at Tuesday’s meeting. The motion was made by school director Marianne Neel, without explanation.

Mrs. Neel was joined by school directors Shauna D’Alessandro, David Graham, John Hosmer, Carolyn Bourgeois in voting to reinstate Mr. Shar. Mrs. Neel could not be reached for comment on why she made the motion, which came as a surprise to some board members, team parents, the superintendent and the solicitor.

Advertise with us

School board President Anthony Angotti said he had no idea the vote was coming up at the meeting and said that the board had received no new information on Mr. Shar since he had been suspended.

Joseph Mendyk, whose daughter is a freshman who played in a summer league under Mr. Shar, said the reinstatement caught everyone by surprise. “We went through the process and we thought something would be done. Then this bombshell was dropped on us to rehire Coach Shar with no investigation. They started the process but never finished it,” said

Mr. Shar could not be reached for comment after the vote. But in a Sept. 25 interview with the Post-Gazette, he said: “This is a parent issue.”

The parents said after the Sept. 23 school board meeting at which Mr. Shar and his assistant coach Glenn Cerra were suspended with pay they expected district officials to look into their concerns and come up with a solution to the problem. At the time, their daughters returned to the open gyms being held for the team.

During the suspensions of Mr. Shar and Mr. Cerra, assistant coach Craig D’Alessandro, who is the brother-in-law of school director Shauna D’Alessandro, was left in charge of the open gyms being held for the girls basketball program.

Advertise with us

Hearings for Mr. Shar and Mr. Cerra were scheduled and after Mr. Cerra attended his hearing, he decided to resign and was given a buyout. That separation agreement was on the agenda at Tuesday’s meeting. However, Mr. Shar did not show up for the three hearings that were set for him, according to Superintendent Michael Panza and solicitor Ira Weiss.

At the first open gym held after Tuesday’s vote, four players attended, Mr. Panza said.

Parents said complaints about Mr. Shar’s treatment of players first were reported last February. But his contract was recommended for renewal.

After playing for Mr. Shar in a summer league, a number of players complained to their parents that they no longer wanted to play for Mr. Shar.

Parents, and sometimes the players, attended a number of meetings with administrators, including high school principal Christopher Sefcheck, athletic director Bill Cherpak and human resources director Lindsay Pfister. After one of the meetings, Mr. Shar had his attorney send cease and desist letters to three parents in an attempt to get them to stop their complaints, said Eric Zoglmann, whose daughter is a junior and was a lead scorer on the team last year.

Advertise with us

“We were outraged. Furious,” Mr. Zoglmann said.

David Willing, whose daughter is a senior who refuses to return to playing for Mr. Shar, and other parents said the basic issue is Mr. Shar’s lack of respect for his players and an abrasive coaching style that includes screaming and public humiliation of the players.

“This is not about playing time. This is not about wins and losses. It’s all about how he is treating these girls. There is no respect,” Mr. Mendyk said.

Mary Niederberger: mniederberger@post-gazette.com; 412-263-1590. On Twitter @Marynied.