Former West Mifflin Area School District assistant business manager Phil Martell has filed a countersuit against the district and some individual officials maintaining they have defamed and slandered him and tried to interfere with his ability to make a living.
The 14-point countersuit, filed by attorney Scott Lautner, is included with Mr. Martell’s response to a January lawsuit the district filed against him for what it claimed was Mr. Martell’s failure to repay $5,174 in tuition reimbursements he owed the district. Mr. Martell’s suit asks for in excess of $25,000 in damages for each of the 14 points.
Named in the countersuit are the West Mifflin Area School District, superintendent Daniel Castagna, solicitor Matthew Racunas and school Directors Phil Shar and Michael Price.
In addition to slander and defamation, the countersuit accuses district officials of fraud for failure to investigate accusations before discussing them publicly or filing suit and of impugning Mr. Martell’s professional reputation with his new employer, the Connellsville Area School District.
Mr. Racunas called the countersuit “completely meritless” and said the district will vigorously defend it.
Mr. Martell was the assistant business manager in West Mifflin for several years until he resigned in December 2009. He is also the president of the Elizabeth Forward school board and the current business manager of the Wilkinsburg School District. He is set to start as the business manager in Connellsville this month.
On Monday, it was reported in the Post-Gazette that the Allegheny County district attorney’s office has sought Mr. Martell’s travel expense records from the Wilkinsburg and West Mifflin Area districts and the Allegheny Intermediate Unit.
West Mifflin school directors voted in March to pursue an investigation of Mr. Martell’s expense reimbursements after school Director Phil Shar, at the March 19 board workshop meeting, said the district had evidence that Mr. Martell may have filed duplicate travel reimbursement reports with West Mifflin and the AIU.
Superintendents in West Mifflin and Wilkinsburg confirmed a district attorney’s representative requested Mr. Martell’s expense reimbursement records last week as did AIU executive director Linda Hippert. It’s unclear if Elizabeth Forward is part of the investigation because superintendent Bart Rocco declined to comment on the matter.
While the countersuit doesn’t specifically mention the district attorney’s investigation, it accuses Mr. Shar of making slanderous remarks at school board meetings accusing Mr. Martell of criminal conduct.
It also accuses the district of wrongful use of civil proceedings, saying it and Mr. Racunas failed to investigate the law and facts for their assertions against Mr. Martell, lacked probable cause and used the allegations “for political gain in the upcoming election.”
Mr. Martell is running for re-election to the Elizabeth Forward school board.
The complaint also accuses Mr. Castagna and Mr. Racunas of fraud for allegedly misleading the school board,
The countersuit accuses Mr. Price of slander for making defamatory statements when he contacted the human resources director of the Connellsville district and “indicated that Mr. Martell has criminal charges pending.”
According to the suit, those comments “impugned Mr. Martell’s trade or profession” and “accused him of serious crimes.”
It alleges that Mr. Price, who knew Mr. Martell had been hired as the new business manager in Connellsville, attempted to interfere with Mr. Martell’s new employer and “prospective economic advantage” and with Mr. Martell’s “contractual relations” with his new employer.
The countersuit also alleges a violation of the Sunshine Act because the board did not vote publicly to approve the tuition lawsuit against Mr. Martell.
In his response to the suit filed to collect the $5,174 in tuition payments, Mr. Martell said he does not owe the money because he was not an Act 93 employee in West Mifflin.
The district contended in its suit that Mr. Martell was employed by Pennsylvania Act 93, which covers certain administrators, and district policy states that such employees who receive benefits must remain in the school district at least five years or repay the tuition reimbursements.
Mary Niederberger: mniederberger@post-gazette.com or 412-263-9512.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.