Pittsburgh police sensed something wasn’t quite right about what they said was a toy drive organizer’s tall tale that someone broke into an East Hills community center and stole 383 gifts just before Christmas.
“Obviously, we felt something was amiss,” Sgt. William Vollberg of the burglary unit said Monday.
What they found after an investigation that involved “countless” hours reviewing surveillance video was that the theft never took place at all.
“I believe the toys were ultimately given out to kids in the community,” the sergeant said. “I don’t think the organizer kept and sold them.”
Police charged that organizer, 49-year-old Carmen Randall, via summons Friday with making a false report to law enforcement. Also the president of the East Hills Resident Council, she declined to comment to a Pittsburgh Post-Gazette reporter Monday but told WPXI-TV last week that she was being blamed for something she didn’t do.
Sgt. Vollberg said surveillance footage shows that the load of Toys for Tots picked up from the Strip District distribution center sat undisturbed in the corner of a room at the Bracey Club House during the time the burglary was alleged to have taken place sometime on Dec. 21. Minor damage on the interior door to the room where the gifts were stored had already been there, he said.
Read More
“It’s clear that nothing moved, nothing is touched,” he said. “The stack of toys didn’t move.”
How the number 383 came about “nobody knows,” but a number that precise and other details raised some eyebrows, the sergeant said.
“It’s one thing to say, ‘Hey, I think something happened.’ It’s another thing to have a very specific story and series of events which upon investigation is [found to be] completely fabricated.”
Molly Born: mborn@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1944 or on Twitter @molly_born.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.