The alleged theft of hundreds of Christmas toys from an East Hills community center that led to an outpouring of donations for needy kids never happened, Pittsburgh police said Friday.
Public safety spokeswoman Sonya Toler said police filed charges via summons Friday against Carmen Randall, 49, president of the East Hills Resident Council and organizer of the toy drive, for making a false report to law enforcement.
“There is absolutely no evidence that someone broke into the center and removed the presents,” Ms. Toler said, noting that police used surveillance video as part of the investigation.
“We can’t speak to her reasoning. That’s something only she can answer.”
In an interview with WPXI-TV, Ms. Randall said, “I’m angry. I’m being blamed for something I didn’t do.
“Who broke the door, because it surely wasn’t me,” she said. “What happened to the toys?”
Read More
Police last month said that on Dec. 21, someone kicked in the door of the Bracey Club House in the 2400 block of Bracey Avenue and stole at least 383 gifts stored there. Officials collected more than $15,000 in gift cards, hundreds of presents and a replacement truckload of toys from Toys for Tots in time for the holiday.
Ms. Toler said she believes the charge, a misdemeanor, marks the “end of the investigation.”
Zone 5 Cmdr. Jason Lando said in an email that burglary detectives spent “a great deal of time and effort attempting to track down the individual(s) responsible for the theft. During the course of reviewing security videos and interviewing various witnesses, it became apparent to the detectives that no burglary occurred. ...
“While a number of children would not have received Christmas gifts were it not for the incredible generosity of the Pittsburgh community, it was determined that an actual burglary never occurred. Detectives continue to investigate the reason for the missing gifts.
“We cannot thank the public enough for their outpouring of support and we want to ensure the community that their donations will be used for months and hopefully years to come ... to provide food, clothing, and other essentials to less fortunate children in our neighborhoods.”
Molly Born: mborn@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1944 or on Twitter @molly_born. Madasyn Czebiniak contributed.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.