Plum police and the Allegheny County District Attorney’s office Tuesday began investigating whether a former teacher charged with having sex with a student and then intimidating her drove past his alleged victim’s house last month while on house arrest and, if so, whether that violated his bail conditions.

Jason E. Cooper, who faces trial next month on various sex and intimidation charges, could not be reached for comment. His attorney, Michael DeRiso, said, “I can’t help you because this is the first I’m hearing about it.”

Regardless of where Mr. Cooper was on Dec. 23 at 4 p.m. — the date and time of the alleged sighting by the daughter of a Plum Borough School District board member — the authorities might have another issue to sort out: Why did it take 13 days for an investigation to begin after a complaint was made to the police on the day of the sighting?

On Tuesday, nearly two weeks after the complaint, a Plum detective spoke with a prosecutor about the situation; later in the day, the detective, Mark Focareta, and Scott Evans, an investigator with the DA’s office, interviewed the people who made the complaint — school board member Vicky Roessler and her teenage daughter. Also Tuesday, Plum police requested from the county’s adult probation services division information about Mr. Cooper’s electronic monitoring.

Advertise with us

According to his bail conditions, Mr. Cooper is on house arrest but is permitted to go on work release. It is unclear whether he is currently employed. He is forbidden from having contact with his alleged victim, witnesses or potential witnesses. The type of monitoring device Mr. Cooper wears does not have GPS capability, meaning it can reveal only whether he is at home when he is supposed to be, not where he is if he is out.

Plum police Chief Jeffrey Armstrong acknowledged that a complaint about Mr. Cooper came in, but said holiday vacations, officer training and a lack of responsiveness by the district attorney’s office combined to prevent a quicker response. The DA’s office, however, disputed the timeline provided by Plum and said the first time assistant district attorney Evan Lowry heard from Plum Detective Mark Focareta was late afternoon Monday.

This latest twist comes nearly a year after a sex scandal embroiled the school district, leading to the arrests of four teachers, a grand jury investigation and the execution of search warrants at the school.

Mr. Cooper was arrested Feb. 10 for his sexual relationship with a former student. About two weeks later, he was charged with intimidation after police said he called his alleged victim. Three other teachers in the district have been charged, two with having sex with students and one for intimidating one of the alleged victims.

The Pittsburgh Post-Gazette began making inquiries about the situation Dec. 24 after learning of the complaint made by Mrs. Roessler. According to Mrs. Roessler’s account, her daughter saw a man she believed to be Mr. Cooper drive by his alleged victim’s house. She told her mother, who called the non-emergency number for the Plum police. Mrs. Roessler said she left a message on a recording saying that her daughter saw something she thought the police should know about and left her number for a return call.

Advertise with us

After waiting a short time without getting a response, Mrs. Roessler contacted a Plum police officer she knew, Dan Moriarty. She said the officer told her to put her daughter’s account in writing and email it to him.

Mrs. Roessler sent the email to Officer Moriarty’s personal and work accounts Dec. 23 at 4:46 p.m. The email said the teen saw a small green car passing by the alleged victim’s house.

“We didn’t make eye contact because he was focused on the house. I had Mr. Cooper for Chemistry the 2013-2014 school year and study hall the year after for part of the year. I am easily able to identify the face of Mr. Cooper and the man in the green car was Mr. Cooper,” the email said.

Chief Armstrong confirmed that Officer Moriarty forwarded the email to Detective Focareta and Lt. Lanny Conley. A text message from Officer Moriarty to Mrs. Roessler indicates that the officer spoke with the “arresting officer” — Mark Focareta — on Dec. 23. However, the chief said, the detective was on vacation and did not see the email until Dec. 29, and the lieutenant was out of the office until Monday.

The chief claimed that Detective Focareta left a voice mail for Mr. Lowry on Dec. 29 requesting a call back. Mike Manko, the DA’s spokesman, said Mr. Lowry did not have any such message on either his work or cell phone.

Advertise with us

Chief Armstrong said that the detective was in training Dec. 30 and 31. That was followed by a holiday and two days off. When Detective Focareta did not hear back, according to the chief, he called again on Jan. 4 and left another message — at 4:52 p.m., after Mr. Lowry had left for the day, according to the DA’s office.

Detective Focareta spoke to another prosecutor on Tuesday and then heard back from Mr. Lowry in the afternoon, the chief said.

Jonathan D. Silver: jsilver@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1962 or on Twitter @jsilverpg. Mary Niederberger: mniederberger@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1590 or on Twitter @MaryNied.