The attorney for a former Plum high school teacher charged with having sex with a student argued that because the alleged victim was 18, there was no exploitation or child abuse.
Common Pleas Judge David R. Cashman didn’t buy it — denying a defense motion to dismiss the charges against Jason Cooper and postponing trial until Nov. 17.
Jason Cooper, 38, of Monroeville is charged with institutional sexual assault, corruption of minors, selling or furnishing liquor to minors and intimidating a witness or victim stemming from allegations that he had a relationship with an 18-year-old student.
Police arrested Mr. Cooper in February.
Before arguing motions, both sides stipulated that the alleged victim and Mr. Cooper exchanged personal cell phone numbers in November, communicated through text messages and Twitter through December, that she spent a night at his home over Christmas break, and went on a date to a movie and for coffee at Starbucks afterward in January.
Defense attorney Michael DeRiso repeatedly said that morally what happened between his client and the alleged victim was a problem, but that, technically, she was a consenting adult.
Read More
“So, it’s OK if your daughter hops in bed with her teacher?” Judge Cashman asked Mr. DeRiso.
“No, it’s not OK. I’m not suggesting that is OK,” he answered. But, he continued, corruption of a minor requires that there was sexual contact, and in this case, that didn’t happen until after the alleged victim turned 18.
“Although what took place was inappropriate, there’s no evidence of sexual relations before her 18th birthday,” Mr. DeRiso said.
The defense attorney said he did not believe there was intimidation — or exploitation — in the case.
Judge Cashman vehemently disagreed, recounting the messages exchanged, that Mr. Cooper had the teen spend a night at his home when his wife and children were out of town, and that he gave her Long Island iced tea.
“That’s not exploiting somebody?” the judge asked. “You’re softening her up and going in for the killer strike. ‘I know I have a wounded victim.’ ”
Assistant district attorney Evan Lowry agreed, arguing that Mr. Cooper had been grooming the teen.
“He, essentially, has been laying the groundwork since she was a sophomore in high school,” he said.
Mr. Lowry also disagreed with Mr. DeRiso’s claim that Mr. Cooper, who he described as “tearful and apologetic,” was not intimidating the alleged victim when he called her after his arrest.
“All of this is emotional manipulation. ‘I still love you. Don’t testify. We can be together after this.’ He’s still trying to control her.”
Mr. DeRiso argued that the charge of institutional sexual assault is overbroad and should not apply in a case involving an 18-year-old student.
“It was meant to protect minors,” he said.
As Mr. DeRiso argued, Judge Cashman cut him off.
“You’re kidding me,” he said three times. “You mean to tell me you don’t believe the Legislature believes a student in a high school needs to be protected?”
“That’s not what I said,” Mr. DeRiso argued.
Instead, the lawyer continued, the way the law was written, it could conceivably apply to college students or law or medical students who might have consensual relationships with their professors, because it is not specific enough and simply states “students.”
“There’s no limit,” Mr. DeRiso said.
But Mr. Lowry argued that the law obviously applies to any high school student —18 or not.
“Nothing changes when someone turns 18 in high school,” he said. “Teachers still have control. Students still have to go to class. Eighteen is not the magical number, and the Pennsylvania legislature knew that.
“Teachers can’t have sex with students, and that is the plain reading of this statute.”
Paula Reed Ward: pward@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2620 or on Twitter: @PaulaReedWard.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.