A former Plum high school teacher charged with having sex with a female student could become today the first of three educators arrested in connection with a school district sex scandal to stand trial.
Jason Cooper, 38, of Monroeville is scheduled for trial at 9 a.m. on a variety of felony and other charges before Judge David R. Cashman of Allegheny County Common Pleas Court. Chief trial deputy district attorney Daniel Fitzsimmons said Tuesday there is a “real possibility” that the case will move forward, though the judge is first set to address motions filed by Mr. Cooper’s attorney, Michael DeRiso, to dismiss the charges.
Mr. DeRiso is not denying that his client, who is a former science teacher, and the student had relations.
Whether those relations were against the law, however, is the key question, according to Mr. DeRiso.
“This is not a whodunit. I’m not going to waste Judge Cashman’s time,” Mr. DeRiso said Tuesday. “He did it. It’s just a question of whether it’s illegal vs. immoral.”
Mr. DeRiso indicated he likely would ask for a non-jury trial.
Read More
Charges against Mr. Cooper, 38, include institutional sexual assault, corruption of minors and intimidation of a witness or victim.
Mr. Cooper was one of a trio of high school teachers arrested by Plum police. He and Joseph Ruggieri, a suspended English teacher, each is charged with having sex with different female students and with trying to intimidate their alleged victims by contacting them after criminal charges were filed.
A third teacher, Drew Zoldak, was charged with intimidation after police say he called Mr. Ruggieri’s alleged victim to the front of his classroom and humiliated her.
Since then, District Attorney Stephen A. Zappala Jr.’s office has been using an investigating grand jury to probe whether educators in the Plum school district had long tolerated inappropriate conduct involving teachers and students while looking the other way.
Mr. DeRiso has argued that the charge of institutional sexual assault is “unconstitutionally overbroad” and that there is no legitimate state interest in “regulating private conduct between consenting adults, even where the relationship began as teacher/student.”
During a preliminary hearing, Mr. Cooper’s alleged victim testified that she did not have sex with the defendant until after her 18th birthday. Court filings indicate that Mr. Cooper was not the teen’s teacher during the period of their relationship.
In a response last month, assistant district attorney Evan Lowry argued for keeping the charges in place, claiming that Mr. Cooper groomed the student starting when she was 17 and “enticed and encouraged” her to have sex.
“The [Pennsylvania] statute’s plain language reveals the intent of the General Assembly, to prohibit sexual contact between school employees who have direct contact with a student of the school, which clearly includes teachers, and a student of that school,” Mr. Lowry wrote.
“The statute provides reasonable standards for school personnel to gauge their conduct — namely, sexual contact with students is forbidden.”
Jonathan D. Silver: jsilver@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1962 or on Twitter @jsilverpg.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.