At least a dozen students who were in the same class as the alleged victim of an institutional sexual assault by a former Plum Senior High School teacher said they never saw or heard another teacher, Drew Zoldak, make a reference to the teen or point her out in relation to the ongoing investigation.

Their statements to police are included in a motion filed Friday by Mr. Zoldak’s attorney, who is asking a judge to dismiss the charges against his client because he claims there is insufficient evidence for the prosecution to win a conviction.

Mr. Zoldak, 40, of New Kensington is charged with two counts of intimidation of a witness after the Allegheny County District Attorney's office said he identified the young woman allegedly victimized by Joseph Ruggieri, an English teacher in the school, during class this spring.

According to the criminal complaint, Mr. Zoldak on April 20 told students in his forensic class that he had been absent the previous Friday because he was being questioned by detectives “because of her,” and pointed at the alleged victim, she testified at his preliminary hearing May 27.

Advertise with us

The prosecution also said Mr. Zoldak called the teen to the front of the class and publicly stated that they would be starting a unit on “sexual assault” the next week, and asked if she was OK with that.

However, according to the motion filed Friday by Mr. Zoldak’s defense attorney, Alexander Lindsay, that version of events is not true.

Instead, Mr. Lindsay said that 12 of the students in that class who were interviewed by investigators within days of the incident said they did not see or hear Mr. Zoldak do what the alleged victim said.

According to the supplemental investigation reports by Plum High School Resource Officer Joseph Little, one student said he didn’t recall Mr. Zoldak pointing at anyone in class that day. Nick Poprocky told the officer he was the one who asked why Mr. Zoldak had been absent April 17. “Mr. Zoldak answered him by saying, ‘I had a meeting downtown.’ As he made that comment, Mr. Zoldak pointed over his shoulder away from the students. Nick stated that at no time did Mr. Zoldak point to the alleged victim and say, ‘because of her.’”

Another student, Kaylie Rypcinski, gave a similar statement, saying that Mr. Zoldak said, “‘Sorry, I had a meeting with authorities.’ When the students asked what for, Mr. Zoldak responded by pointing backward, the opposite direction of students, toward ex-teacher [Jason] Cooper’s classroom.’” Mr. Cooper is the other teacher charged with having a sexual relationship with students.

Advertise with us

The alleged victim from Mr. Zoldak’s class acknowledged at the preliminary hearing that Mr. Zoldak did use his head to motion toward Mr. Cooper’s classroom. But she said he also used his hand to point at her, which made her want to “go away and hide,” she said.

“I thought that nobody knew that I was the victim of another case, and in a way, like, makes me think that I’m doing the wrong thing, and I shouldn’t go forward and cooperate with you and the detective,” she testified.

At least one student interviewed said that Mr. Zoldak did mention that they would be starting a lesson on “sexual assault” the next week, but did not recall that he addressed the alleged victim about it.

Mr. Zoldak is asking Common Pleas Judge David R. Cashman to hold a hearing on his petition and, ultimately, dismiss the charges.

Mr. Lindsay argued in his motion that the DA’s office cannot prove the required elements of the crime beyond a reasonable doubt. Those elements include that Mr. Zoldak’s actions were designed to keep the student from “informing or reporting to any law enforcement officer ... any information, document or thing relating to the commission of a crime,” and that he did so “with the intent to, or knowledge, that his conduct would impair/​impede/​prevent or interfere with the administration of criminal justice.”

Advertise with us

Even if taking the alleged victim’s testimony as true, Mr. Lindsay wrote, there is nothing that shows Mr. Zoldak’s conduct “rose to the level of intimidation.”

“There is certainly no evidence to establish the defendant’s intent to intimidate the victim to refrain from informing or reporting” information relating to a crime.

Paula Reed Ward: pward@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2620 or on Twitter @PaulaReedWard.