There’s something magical about the world’s cold places, and particularly the contrast with the warmth of the human civilizations that persevere there.

In fact, I have a question I like to ask friends as a conversation starter (and maybe personality test): If you could only visit either the Arctic or the South Seas, and whichever one you don’t choose you are banned from forever, which one would you pick?

To my surprise, most people have agreed with me that the chilly austerity of the North draws them in, even more than the allurements of the tropics.

This is why, I suspect, the Carnegie Museum of Natural History’s Polar World exhibit — decommissioned this weekend after more than four decades in service — generated such loyalty. Indeed, I suspect the exhibit, in turn, nurtured my own love of the Arctic.

Advertise with us

Polar memories

While, like all kids, I went through a dinosaur phase, and the hall of minerals and gems was always a highlight, Polar World formed some of the most lasting childhood memories of the museum.

This was mostly, I think, because it was so immersive. It felt cold just walking through the glass doors.

I remember the first time I took my own kids to see Polar World, decades since I had last visited. I was relieved to see so little had changed: There was the same Inuit mannequin spearing the same seal through the ice; the same full-scale walrus, plump and menacing; and of course the same igloo, which little kids especially love to explore.

Yet even as an adult, the interior of the mock igloo felt safe and cozy and magical. It’s a warm and snug home but it’s made of ice — that wonderful Arctic contrast in its purest form. You can imagine the relief of entering from the forbidding elements outside. You wouldn’t want to live that way forever but, if you’re like me, you’d like to give it a shot for a day or a week.

Anya Sostek’s article about the closure revealed to me the obsessive lengths the Carnegie Museums went to, back in the 1980s when Arctic expeditions were among the institution’s projects, in order to bring Polar World to life. Curators made plaster casts of animals and even the faces of Inuit people themselves, so that the dioramas would be as accurate as possible. It was a million-dollars effort (in 1983 dollars) that paid off in four decades of wonder.

Advertise with us

Objects or subjects?

It’s true that the unchanging nature of the exhibit had another side: In some respects it was visibly quite dated. The photographs documenting “contemporary” Arctic life looked like those from reference books available in 1990s school libraries — because that’s basically what they were.

There was also an underlying tension within the exhibit, one that’s become more acute with enhanced sensitivity toward the treatment and presentation of Indigenous cultures. While it’s good and normal for museums of natural history to include an anthropological element — that is, the study of human cultures — this can fade into the presentation of human beings as exotic specimens, like the stuffed dodo bird or the (stunning) Savannah biome diorama.

The Carnegie is particularly sensitive to this after the discovery of human remains within the world-famous 1867 diorama “Lion Attacking a Dromedary,” which had been featured in the wildlife halls. It is now behind frosted glass in the museum’s main hall, as a kind of exhibit about museum exhibits.

In this light, for instance the care placed into making plaster casts of actual Inuit faces might take on a different countenance. Was that an act of humanization — making the exhibit represent a real human face rather than a generic “Inuit face” — or dehumanization — turning a real human face into an object of exotic fascination, separating it from the person it belonged to?

Expanded horizons

These are thorny questions, with which the Carnegie is also grappling as it plans to expand its Egyptology exhibit into Polar World’s space. That is a little easier, however, because the exhibit explicitly covers an ancient civilization, while Polar World aimed to present both the historic and contemporary Arctic.

Advertise with us

I would say one word, though, in favor of Polar World and similar projects: wonder. While we must be careful about reducing human beings and cultures to mere objects of study, when done well, these exhibits can and do elevate their subjects by making them part of the imaginations of museum goers for the rest of their lives.

They can (in a sense) restore the humanity of subjects who have been too often treated as less than human.

For 43 years, Polar World expanded and formed our imaginations with Arctic wonder — and in so doing, it served its subjects well.

Brandon McGinley’s pervious column was “Is compulsory service the answer to teenage chaos?”