It’s a wonderful thing to find Civilian Conservation Corps and Works Progress Administration projects in the wild.

Several years ago we hosted a First Communion party for our eldest at Riverview Park’s Valley Refuge Shelter, a decades-old park building constructed more solidly than most homes today by the National Youth Administration — a subgroup of the 1930’s-founded WPA that focused on providing work for people age 18 to 25.

Projects like that stone and wood park building represent a spirit of solidarity and craftsmanship that feels very distant from the individualism, alienation and carelessness of contemporary American society. That they endure — that these physical manifestations of solidarity and hard work remain visible and valuable nearly a century on — testifies to the timelessness of the values they represent.

How gratifying and empowering it must have felt as a young person during the Great Depression to regard a finished project, whether a shelter or a trail or a road or a bridge.

Advertise with us

To be able to say, amidst an economic crisis that became a crisis of meaning and purpose for those whose work was no longer valued by a collapsed marketplace: “I built that. I have contributed to my community. I have helped to support my family.”

The purely economic impact of the New Deal is contested by the experts. But the social impact was undeniably worthwhile.

And I wonder if a similar program might be what America needs today.

Despair and chaos

It’s difficult for most grown-ups to generate a theory of mind for the teens who brawl in Market Square, East Liberty and elsewhere. Even for adolescents — an age group not known for careful consideration and long-term thinking — these behaviors are senseless and extreme.

Clearly social media plays a massive role. The platforms allow for gatherings to be organized at a moment’s notice. “Fights” are often staged to generate content (though the performance often spills into real fisticuffs or worse). Attracting police attention only increases the social media clout of the kids on the scene.

Advertise with us

I also continue to believe — based on conversations with outreach workers who know the kids better than almost anyone — that most who show up to, say, a 400-person mob in East Liberty are not there to participate in violence. They may be there to witness violence and violence may then engulf them, but for the vast majority actually inflicting or receiving harm is not the point.

Yet chaotic behaviors have a way of spreading. You start on the periphery of chaos, then end up in the middle. You start as a curious onlooker, then end as an enthusiastic participant.

The one thing that’s clear is that the allure of chaos always emerges from despair — from a lack of hope for one’s own future and for one’s community, which removes a crucial barrier to making self-destructive and community-destructive choices.

It’s in this context that the New Deal programs have sprung to mind.

Teaching solidarity

What if America exercised those civic muscles once again? What if, like nearly 100 other countries around the world, the United States required its young people to perform some kind of national service?

Advertise with us

This wouldn’t necessarily be military service, but for those who want that, it could be. More often, it would be the kind of projects that we associate with the New Deal alphabet soup agencies, updated for this century: more maintaining aging pieces of infrastructure than building new ones.

There’s a ton of work to be done, but the projects themselves would really be a secondary concern. National service would be about breaking down social barriers and building up a sense of ownership of and responsibility for one’s country and local communities.

Americans lack a shared experience across lines of race, class and other categories that limit our perspective on the breadth of the American experience. This program would teach, not with words but with actions, both that we all have a place here and that our place must be partially carved out by our own efforts, by our own contributions to the communities we share.

It would generate a sense of meaning, belonging and shared responsibility that has atrophied — a process accelerated by social media, which provides the illusion of connection but primarily alienates us from one another.

Extraordinary measures

It’s easy to imagine all the objections coming to mind, because they’re also in mine: This would be far too expensive and complicated for the U.S. government to pull off. Modern safety and union rules wouldn’t allow young people to work on the most needed projects. It would turn into a partisan indoctrination camp for whichever party is in power.

Advertise with us

I get it.

But consider this thought. The WPA, CCC, NYA and so on were unprecedented responses to an unprecedented economic crisis. President Franklin D. Roosevelt and his advisers realized that extraordinary measures (and risks) were needed to keep the country from falling apart.

What if we are, in fact, living through a social crisis just as acute as the economic crisis of the Great Depression? What if the alienation, the anti-sociality, the despair — all exacerbated by smartphones and social media — present as much of a threat to communities and the country as what America faced a century ago?

If that’s the case, then our thinking must not be constrained by what is typical and comfortable. That’s how we got here. There are examples, hidden in plain sight, of what a previous America-in-crisis was able to build.

And in so doing, the country rebuilt its very self.

Brandon McGinley’s previous column was “The evolution of Allegheny County Council.”