The Pittsburgh of 2025 would have been difficult to envision a quarter-century ago.
Artificial intelligence was a term known mainly in the computer labs of Carnegie Mellon University. Real estate in Lawrenceville was selling for closer to $100,000 than $1 million. And the city was on the verge of literal bankruptcy.
So picturing the Pittsburgh of 2050 — jumping ahead a quarter century from now — may be a fool’s errand. But it’s worth a try.
“I think Pittsburgh’s best days are ahead of it,” said urban theorist Richard Florida. “Pittsburgh has the opportunity to invest in a new kind of innovation hub to build things to serve its people.”
Leading up to the year 2000, Mr. Florida was an urban studies professor at CMU. He watched in 1996 as the search engine Lycos spun off from CMU and then moved its operation to Boston, chasing a more vibrant city.
He made a name for himself with a bestselling book in 2002, “The Rise of the Creative Class,” pointing out a correlation between prosperous cities and those with a relatively large population of workers such as engineers, scientists and artists.
Read More
He argued that cities should prioritize luring those workers in their economic development efforts — rather than using public funds to build stadiums or provide industrial incentives.
Though his thesis has drawn criticism over the years, Mr. Florida still believes in the basic premise.
And as he looks ahead to 2050, he predicts remote work — made possible by technological advances and accelerated by the COVID-19 pandemic — as the driver of some of the most fundamental changes to come to Pittsburgh.
“What the COVID pandemic taught us is that downtowns are no longer about work,” said Mr. Florida, who now lives mainly in Toronto. “The downtown of the future is a downtown built around sports, entertainment and activity. Where Pittsburgh did something right — and I was wrong — was the stadiums, really making this fantastic entertainment complex.”
With remote work, Pittsburgh also has the opportunity to market itself through its quality of life. People don’t have to work in Pittsburgh to live here. They might relocate to the city for access to cultural amenities and more affordable housing while working remotely for jobs elsewhere.
Pittsburgh should lean even further into entertainment in transforming Downtown and surrounding areas over the next quarter century, he said, pointing to Miami and Nashville as cities that have successfully marketed their “fun” quotient to tourists and residents.
And while Pittsburgh may continue economically to lean into the “eds and meds” industries that helped the city transform from its industrial past, Mr. Florida also cautioned that Pittsburgh still needs to keep itself affordable to keep residents here and draw remote workers from higher-priced cities.
“I would say to Pittsburgh to be careful what you wish for,” he said, noting that the tech industry has changed the culture and cost in cities such as San Francisco and Austin. “You have to be really strategic so that what happened to Austin doesn’t happen to Pittsburgh.”
For native Pittsburgher Ahmed Tacumba Turner Jr., preserving the character of Pittsburgh’s past is important as it looks to the future.
“As we are thinking about investing to boost the tax base, we need to maintain the character of Pittsburgh, and to do it so that people who are from here can take advantage,” said Mr. Turner, founder of Pittsburgh-based arts organization The Future is Black. “Where does that lead us if Pittsburgh is a baby San Francisco?”
It’s a question that the city of Pittsburgh government is also exploring as it crafts its PGH 2050 Comprehensive Plan.
The city is in the midst of a two-year, five-phase process to create the plan, and is currently in the fourth phase, “scenario planning.”
Envisioning the future, the planners present three scenarios for Pittsburgh over the next quarter century, with projected benefits and tradeoffs.
In the first scenario, for example, Pittsburgh could focus on building population, adding 150,000 residents to fill in vacant housing while prioritizing non-degree, middle-wage job growth. In the second, the city would focus on adding jobs, prioritizing advanced-degree workers and increased development. And in the third scenario, Pittsburgh would focus on climate resilience, prioritizing green-sector jobs and building infrastructure less dependent on cars.
The plan as a whole “will focus on racial and social equity, climate justice, and building a strong and sustainable economy,” according to its online engagement hub. “These pillars will ensure that the plan reflects the needs of all residents, especially those who have been overlooked in the past.”
Who benefits from development in Pittsburgh — and who doesn’t — has been and will likely continue to be a point of tension over the next quarter century.
The issue came to a head in rapidly gentrifying East Liberty in 2018, when the words “There Are Black People in the Future” — posted on a billboard as part of a rotating art project — were removed by the building’s landlord.
“A lot of good things have happened to rebound the city,” said Mr. Turner, of Sheraden. “But the benefits haven’t always been even, to say the least.”
Mr. Turner, 31, was barely in elementary school in 2000. Growing up in the West End of Pittsburgh, he would cut through the woods walking to school, sometimes chased by wild turkeys.
He was curious about the environment, and he majored in environmental science at Slippery Rock University before starting a career in Pittsburgh as an artist and an urban farmer, with Grow Pittsburgh.
Over the last few years, Mr. Turner has noticed friends with asthma and eczema — a response, he believes, to environmental stressors. He has also watched creative and professional friends leave for cities such as Chicago, Boston or Charlotte, drawn by bigger cities offering higher wages and more opportunities.
And he has friends who want to live in places with more diverse populations. It’s an issue also highlighted by Mr. Florida, as Pittsburgh has a smaller Latino population and fewer immigrants generally than similarly sized cities.
“Pittsburgh still isn’t attracting enough diversity,” he said, referencing research he had done on immigrants in Pittsburgh versus Toronto. “What people said was that we wanted to go to a place with a deeper immigrant community — we don’t want to be the only ones.”
In the next quarter century, will Pittsburgh be able to incorporate more of the population into its economic success stories?
“I would love to see the story of a comeback city to shared prosperity,” said Mr. Turner. “My hope is that we could shift the narrative from comeback to we’re doing it, and we’re doing it well.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.