Landlords in Pittsburgh can’t reject applicants because of a lack of rental history or because of a history of being homeless or in transitional housing, according to an ordinance recently passed by City Council.

The measure puts Pittsburgh in a small but growing group of cities around the U.S. making “housing status” a protected class. 

The ordinance — sponsored by Councilman Bob Charland and unanimously passed last week — amends Pittsburgh’s civil rights code and gives the Pittsburgh Commission on Human Relations the power to investigate complaints.

Landlords won’t be required to accept any applicant or change their screening criteria — owners can still ask about an applicant’s housing history and run income, credit and background checks — but they can’t use a gap in housing history or homelessness, by itself, as a reason to deny someone.

Advertise with us

“The ‘homeless’ label is a stigma that makes it hard to find permanent housing. This is true even when someone meets all the other criteria,” said Rachel Shepherd, the commission’s executive director. 

‘Housing resumes’ and placement

Chris Soult, ​​deputy director of the Pittsburgh Commission on Human Relations, told council members during a Sept. 22 meeting that the change is in response to an “uptick” in landlords asking applicants for a “housing resume” and using gaps in housing history — during which someone may have spent time in a shelter or lacked a residential address — as reasons of rejection.

As a result, housing organizations are finding it increasingly difficult to place people, and units are remaining vacant for longer, Mr. Soult added.

“If they had the option of a tenant who maybe has a slightly lower credit score and a slightly lower income, but they were chosen over a person who has a gap in their housing history or is getting assistance from an agency, it’s likely because they’re [landlords] making a snap judgment on the fact that that person has a gap in their housing history,” Ms. Shepherd told council members. “That’s the discrimination we’re trying to avoid.”

Under the ordinance, landlords can still ask about current and former “housing status” — which the commission defines as a period of not having a fixed residence, including time spent in transitional housing, a shelter, a medical facility or couch surfing.

Advertise with us

But they can’t use those as reasons to determine someone would be an "unreliable tenant.” 

If Pittsburgh residents suspect they’ve experienced housing discrimination, they can file an online complaint with the commission, which will then work with the nonprofit Fair Housing Partnership of Greater Pittsburgh to investigate.

Investigators will then use matched-pair testing, where two people with different backgrounds will inquire about the same housing unit from the same provider. Based on the treatment they receive, researchers can better identify disparities and gather evidence of discrimination.

If a settlement can’t be reached in cases where the commission finds discrimination, it can bring matters to court.

While the proposal was met with general support from council and ultimately passed, outgoing Councilwoman Theresa Kail-Smith warned of the “unintended consequences” of placing more restrictions on landlords.

Advertise with us

“We're putting so many restrictions on landlords that I think we’re preventing people from wanting to even own in the city of Pittsburgh,” she said during the Sept. 22 meeting.

How it has worked in other states

Similar efforts have surfaced in other cities, such as Louisville, Ky., where then-Mayor Greg Fischer announced in late 2020 that conviction history, homeless status, source of income (including support from federal, state, or local public assistance), and military service records would be protected. 

“Housing, in particular, has been an area where racism and other forms of discrimination still hurt too many people in our city for far too long,” Mr. Fischer said in a news release at the time.

In the years since, certain protections have faced backlash from the state legislature. In 2024, Kentucky lawmakers overrode a veto to pass House Bill 18, which prohibited local governments from passing ordinances requiring landlords to accept public assistance vouchers — effectively gutting parts of the city’s source of income and housing discrimination protections.

Indiana, Iowa and Idaho have enacted similar preemption laws, forbidding cities from expanding local housing protections to cover categories such as source of income. The city of Springfield, Mo., enacted a nondiscrimination law in 2014 protecting LGBTQ+ people in housing, employment and public accommodations — only to have voters repeal it less than a year later, citing concerns over government overreach and religious objections.

Advertise with us

Other cities, however, have kept their protections intact. Washington, D.C., expanded its Human Rights Act in 2022 to explicitly bar discrimination based on “homeless status” and sealed eviction records. 

Complaints are filed with the D.C. Office of Human Rights, which civil rights groups have commended on the rise of fair housing cases docketed in recent years. Since 2019, the office has logged about 70 fair housing complaints annually, according to the D.C.-based Equal Rights Law Center.

But delays in the complaint process appear to have “considerably worsened in the last year,” according to the ERC’s testimony before the D.C. Council performance oversight hearing of the OHR in February.

“The 24 inquiries ERC and its clients filed in FY2024 took, on average, about six months from the date of initial filing to the docketing of the signed charge,” the group said.

Of those charges docketed, it took an average of four months to schedule a mediation, with the longest still pending scheduling as of February, despite the complaint being docketed more than eight months prior, the group added.

Advertise with us

Those types of challenges haven’t stopped other cities from expanding protections.

In Minneapolis, city leaders voted last year to add housing status to their civil rights code, alongside new categories such as weight, height and justice-system involvement. The ordinance went into effect Aug. 1. 

“At a time when the federal administration is advancing attacks on our most vulnerable residents and attempting to strip away our hard-earned civil rights, here in Minneapolis, we are not only defending the rights we have, we are continuing to expand protections against discrimination,” said Minneapolis council member Robin Wonsley in an August news release.

Pittsburgh’s amended ordinance — which has been sent to Mayor Ed Gainey’s desk for his signature — still makes it unlawful for owners to refuse to sell or lease properties to applicants because of race, religion, national origin, sex, gender identity, sexual orientation and disability, among other things.

“There are far too many obstacles to finding housing,” Mr. Charland said in a statement last week. “Many of us are a tragic incident away from losing our home and having to stay in a shelter, sleep on a friend’s couch or live on the streets.”