Despite tight margins in Pittsburgh’s 2026 budget and unresolved issues with declining property tax rates, members of Mayor Ed Gainey's administration said Wednesday they feel the city is still in a strong financial position, a far cry from what other city officials said of the budget.
Mr. Gainey and his staff have long maintained that the city’s finances are in good shape, despite pushback from city council members, the city controller and continued concerns that spending is outpacing revenue.
In Mr. Gainey’s proposed 2026 budget — the last his administration will present — officials anticipate bringing in only $500,000 more than they spend, five-year forecasts showing real estate tax revenue shrinking and taking the rainy-day fund with it.
“We should not be in this position, with this shoe-string budget,” Councilman Anthony Coghill said Wednesday afternoon, adding that there were a number of things in the proposed budget he was concerned about.
City Controller Rachael Heisler said in a statement her office was still reviewing the budget but that it was “simply not an honest document.”
“The numbers may add up on paper, but they do not reflect the reality of the City’s pending costs,” she said, pointing to low overtime payment allocations, an undercount of how many firefighters the city has and an “inadequate and unrealistic” allocation of funds to the city’s fleet of vehicles.
Read More
“Nothing about it adds up for me,” Mr. Coghill said. “There’s a lot of errors in it and things that are not going to hold up.”
One such error, that has already been corrected in the document online, shows the mayor not getting a 3% cost-of-living raise, despite being common practice among city employees not represented by a union.
Director of the Office of Management and Budget Jake Pawlak said at a Wednesday morning press conference that “may be a typo.”
“We didn’t decide to not increase the pay for those positions,” he added. Mr. Gainey was part of a very contentious primary race last spring against Allegheny County Controller Corey O’Connor, who is likely to be the city’s next mayor.
But Mr. Pawlak believes the “financial picture moving into the future looks strong.”
Councilwoman Theresa Kail-Smith, who was the lone “no” vote against the 2025 budget last year, said on Wednesday that right now “this budget has left me with more questions than answers.”
Both council members said they thought the administration could be better allocating money in some of the trust funds to pay for capital improvements.
Mr. Pawlak said the administration looked critically at where they could cut costs without laying off any employees or raising taxes. That included eliminating 50 vacant positions from the budget, some of which came from the Mayor’s office.
Mr. Gainey’s administration had drastically increased the number of staff in his office than prior administrations, and next year’s budget returns to those previous levels.
My Coghill said that alone was an indication of the “mismanagement over the past four years.” If those positions could be eliminated so easily, why were they needed to begin with, Mr. Coghill questioned.
Some of those positions were in the 311 office, which has been moved under the Office of Management and Budget, while others “have been pruned to reflect the realities that we’re facing in terms of producing a balanced budget,” Mr. Pawlak said.
The 2026 budget “will get us through next year with a modest surplus and pay off a significant amount of that debt and see a drop in debt service,” Mr. Pawlak said.
Lingering though, is the falling property tax rates, historically the city’s largest income generator. In 2026, the city anticipates bringing in about $142.8 million from those taxes. By 2030, that number drops to about $138.8 million.
In 2019, before the pandemic and the artificially inflated rates used to calculate tax appeals, the city was bringing in close to $150 million in property taxes.
Mr. Pawlak said the city believes it has finally passed the crest of appeals that saw some major Downtown buildings property assessment drastically decreased, but could still pose problems for the city’s financial future.
Without a countywide reassessment, which likely will come as a state mandate, a tax hike could be necessary, Mr. Pawlak said.
“If a tax increase is eventually necessary here or elsewhere it will be because of … the constant downward pressure on property taxes,” he said.
The city did not raise taxes this year, though the option wasn’t completely off the table.
“It’s always on the table when we start the process,” Mr. Pawlak said. “Ultimately we determined that though the circumstances we were facing did require some adjustments, it wasn’t a big enough shift needed in order to necessitate a tax increase.”
Both Mr. Coghill and Ms. Kail-Smith said Wednesday that they would not vote for a tax increase.
“I think there’s a lot of ways we can look at trimming the fat off this budget,” Mr. Coghill said. “Every dime is a big deal now because of the mismanagement of the last four years.”
Though there was no tax hike proposed this year, the city has to look for other revenue sources, Mr. Pawlak said.
Ms. Heisler in a letter certifying the revenue projections, said they were “reasonable given current economic conditions,” but emphasized the importance of monitoring population retention and bringing in new residents and businesses.
But when it comes to expenses, she had some more drastic concerns.
“The bottom line is that this proposal does not tell the truth about the City’s basic operating expenses,” her statement said. “Keeping people safe and delivering essential services costs money, and right now we aren’t collecting enough revenue to cover the bill. That’s just reality. And that won’t change as long as we try to pretend otherwise.”
Last month at a meeting with the Pittsburgh Economic Club, Ms. Heisler said though the city is in the middle of lean years, she doesn’t think Pittsburgh is near going back under state financial oversight.
“This is a situation we can fight our way out of,” she said. “We need to be smart about how we’re spending money and smart about our growth.”
In the 2026 budget, the city was able to cut about $3 million in non-personnel spending, Mr. Pawlak said.
Another concern in the budget is the dwindling rainy-day fund.
While revenue projections increase over the next five years — hitting an estimated $716.5 million in 2030 — the rainy-day fund is shrinking.
City code requires that the fund balance — similar to the city’s savings account — be at or above 10%. In 2026 the city estimates it will be around 20% but drops to just 10.1% in 2030.
“I am concerned,” Ms. Heisler said earlier this month. “I do not think spending the fund balance is a long-term strategy.”
She added that there is no mechanism in place to prevent the city from spending the fund balance entirely. The city code does not outline any repercussions should the balance fall below 10%.
“There’s no teeth to that requirement,” she said.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.