The Pittsburgh Planning Commission has unanimously approved a measure making it easier to create temporary housing, including tiny homes, for people experiencing homelessness in the city.

The legislation creates a new zoning category dubbed “interim housing,” or facilities designed to provide shelter and support services for individuals working toward permanent housing.

Under the bill, proposed by City Council members Deb Gross and Anthony Coghill, these temporary structures could be built in non-residential districts where hotels and motels are permitted.

During Tuesday’s meeting, James Murray, Ms. Gross’ chief of staff, said the legislation adds needed flexibility in the zoning code to create more housing solutions, where homeless service providers can build new structures or revamp old ones.

Advertise with us

He said these facilities will come with social services and amenities such as heating and bathroom facilities so people “can get back on their feet.”

It has taken more than a year for these zoning changes to move forward, as Ms. Gross and Mr. Coghill first introduced an iteration of the legislation back in November 2023. By the following August, the pair shelved the bill to make way Mayor Ed Gainey’s package of broader fair housing zoning amendments, which the Planning Commission approved.

Blake Plavjack, Mr. Coghill’s chief of staff, said creating a standalone bill for the interim housing provisions could ensure quicker action and avoid possible setbacks with the larger fair housing package.

“The council members believed this issue was too important to leave tied up with a bill that had yet to be introduced in council,” he said.

But the commission’s green light for the bill came with conditions. These include requiring wraparound services, such as counseling and job training, to be part of the facilities' operational plans and removing a provision that limited new projects to approval every four years.

Advertise with us

And still, public participation — or the lack thereof — remained point of contention during Tuesday’s meeting. Carmen Brown, a resident of the East Liberty neighborhood, criticized city officials for failing to provide adequate notice about the meeting and new proposal.

With only a handful of public comments shared in person and online, Ms. Brown said the lack of attendance at the meeting reflected those problems.

Officials assured that additional opportunities for comment will be available as the bill moves to council. But Ms. Brown doesn’t think that’s a sufficient answer.

“I know you keep saying, ‘Well, you know, there's another process, and other people can come,’ ” she said. “What we're talking about right now, because your recommendations do matter. You all need to notify and engage people to come to these meetings first.”

Zoning Administrator Corey Layman explained that outreach efforts had been conducted during the drafting process and the commission remains open to presenting the changes to community groups.

Advertise with us

“To my knowledge, I don't think that there were any communities that raised a specific concern around the interim housing aspect,” he said.

Mr. Layman also said the new bill also ensures interim housing projects require public hearings and zoning board approval — addressing a previous snag point that had drawn criticism from commission members and local residents.

The commissioners were also briefed on another piece of legislation seeking to address the city’s housing crisis.

District 3 Councilman Bob Charland told the commission that his bill builds on previous inclusionary zoning efforts by allowing individual neighborhoods to opt in or out of these policies.

It also creates more flexibility for developers to meet certain affordability thresholds, ranging from 10% to 20% of units in new developments, and offers them subsidies to cover financial gaps from lost rent income.

Advertise with us

He said current inclusionary zoning policies, instituted in Lawrenceville, Bloomfield, Polish Hill and most of Oakland, have fallen short of their goals, creating less than 40 units since 2019.

“I believe that every neighborhood has the capacity to have more affordable units,” Mr. Charland said. “We need them that badly.”

However, Mr. Charland’s proposal faced criticism for vague provisions.

Planning Commission members expressed concerns that the proposal doesn’t determine exactly how neighborhoods become inclusionary, nor does it outline where funding for the developer incentives will come from.

Plus, the bill allows developers to override a neighborhood’s decision to “opt out” and still create inclusionary zoning projects in those areas.

Advertise with us

Planning Commission member Rachel O’Neill said she aligns with the councilman’s goal to create more affordable housing but called the bill “premature.”

The next planning commission meeting will be held on Jan. 28.