Efforts to update Pittsburgh’s group housing regulations have sparked a heated debate over how to balance community concerns with the city’s need for more housing.

City Council currently is considering two opposing bills that would usher in sweeping changes to the zoning process and approval of new housing projects.

But the role of public opinion in the decision-making process is a key issue dividing housing providers, residents and council members alike.

For Councilwoman Theresa Kail-Smith, the answer is clear: Residents should have more say over the types of developments public officials and developers want to build in their neighborhoods, she told the Post-Gazette.

Advertise with us

In response to growing community pushback to housing projects, including the conversion of a shuttered Stanton Heights nursing home into transitional housing, Ms. Kail-Smith introduced a bill this summer. The legislation would require smaller community homes to get council approval and be subjected to public hearings before they could be built.

After Ms. Kail-Smith introduced her bill, she learned that opposing legislation was already in the works. That proposal, introduced by Mayor Ed Gainey’s administration last month, seeks to overhaul city zoning regulations to reduce barriers and create more flexibility.

One key change would streamline the approval process for group homes of up to 10 residents. Under this plan, such homes would be allowed "by right," meaning they could bypass public hearings and special approvals if they met certain criteria.

Ms. Kail-Smith argues that the mayor’s proposal deprives the community of offering input. She opposes the idea of giving the zoning administrator, an unelected official, unilateral authority to approve the conversion of large residential facilities, such as former hospitals or schools, into group homes without any public involvement.

“You wouldn’t plant 10 trees on somebody's street without talking to them, but you're going to put 10 people there that may have certain needs,” she said. “There has to be conversations making sure everybody's reassured and comfortable.”

Advertise with us

City officials have clarified that the administrator’s exception process does include a 21-day public notice requirement. The administration contends that the proposed reforms would address concerns raised by housing providers, who say the current zoning process is often costly and time-consuming.

That’s what Alicia Romano, CEO of Community Human Services, said she experienced when creating the Stanton Heights housing. The program is accommodating 13 people who’ve come from county shelters and need temporary housing assistance while they find jobs and stability.

Two neighbors filed a lawsuit, which is pending, contesting the legality of the facility.

“We had delay after delay trying to get that program up and running because of misinterpretations of the regulations,”  Ms. Romano said.

The zoning board approved the conversion of the former Vincentian De Marillac nursing home in May after two public hearings, and the first residents didn’t move in until September.

Advertise with us
Vincentian De Marillac nursing home in Stanton Heights Wednesday, Oct. 30, 2024. The closed facility is now being used as transitional housing for people experiencing homelessness. (Sebastian Foltz / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

She said she believes Mr. Gainey’s legislation could cut through bureaucratic barriers and speed up the creation of housing for those in need, particularly by repurposing existing buildings, as CHS has.

“People say they're just going to come in and set up homeless shelters on every corner of our community,” Ms. Romano said. “That's not the reality of what's happening, but it's just a fear of the unknown.”

Still, Stanton Heights residents don't feel there’s been enough transparency.

Kenneth Mayben, a resident of Somerville Street for the past 50 years, criticized the lack of communication from CHS and officials, including County Executive Sara Innamorato, who had promised to address residents' concerns last month.

“She said she was going to give some details going forward, what happened, what their plan is,” he said. “But not a word.”

Advertise with us

He said there haven’t been any flyers or updates sent to nearby residents since this summer. He has since added additional security cameras at his property and wants to see better lighting, fencing and monitoring around the facility to improve safety.

Ms. Romano said she believes she has been attentive to community concerns. For the safety of her residents, she said, CHS had to post “No Trespassing” signs due to people entering the property, taking photos and yelling at staff.

“If I have come across as not being transparent, I want to learn more of what I could do,” she said. “I'm going to meetings and I'm responding to people's phone calls. I'm responding to people's emails. I'm answering questions.”

Axel Claussen, whose home on Somerville Street is closest to the facility, stands in contrast with most of his neighbors. He went to one public hearing intending to speak in support of the project, but left early because he didn’t feel comfortable doing so amongst the conflict.

Mr. Claussen said he understands the neighborhood's uncertainty but wonders how housing projects will ever find a place in the city if they are always met with resistance.

Advertise with us

“Why not put them here?” he said. “These people need a place to go. There’s been fear that people will come wandering up the street and create havoc, I don't know. So far, nothing horrible has happened, and I don’t think it's going to be as bad as people believe.”

Ms. Kail-Smith said her bill stills needs a recommendation from the planning commission before heading to council and hopes that can happen before the year ends. A public hearing on Mr. Gainey’s legislation is scheduled for 6 p.m. Wednesday in council chambers.