For two decades, a portion of the Pittsburgh Public School District’s earned income tax revenue has been diverted to the city of Pittsburgh, totaling hundreds of millions of dollars with no end in sight. 

This year alone, the city has received close to $25 million from this diversion. As the school district is now staring down a budget deficit of almost $30 million, it is looking for ways to keep that money in its own accounts, according to the district’s solicitor Ira Weiss. 

“It is just not logical or appropriate," Mr. Weiss said. “One taxing body subsidizing another, and that’s what’s happening here.”

The diversion was part of what Mr. Weiss called a “midnight special” in 2004. At the time, the city was under state financial supervision under Act 47. While the city's finances were in dire shape, the school district had a healthy fund balance.

Advertise with us

As part of the state’s oversight, lawmakers amended the taxing statute to say that one-quarter of 1% of the district’s earned income tax would go to the city. In total, the district collects a 2% earned income tax. 

“It was not talked about,” Mr. Weiss said. The lawmakers “just did it.” 

Mr. Weiss, who has been practicing municipal school law for 51 years, said he has never seen an arrangement like this anywhere else. 

“It’s high time it ends,” he said. “Any attempts at discussions with the city have gone nowhere because they have absolutely no incentive to do anything,”

Within the amended statute, the lawmakers didn’t include a sunset clause, which allows the diversion to continue on indefinitely.

Advertise with us

Gene Walker, president of the Pittsburgh Public School Board, said he understands why the initial diversion was put in place. But what he questions is why a sunset provision was never determined, which would have ended the diversion when the city was out of financial distress. 

“For us as a school district it continues to create issues because we've been facing, obviously, budget deficits for several years, and a lot of that could be solved or at least mitigated significantly if we have that quarter percent coming back to us,” Mr. Walker said. 

School directors this week got a look at the proposed final 2025 budget, which features a $28.1 million deficit, a $7.3 million increase from what was projected in the preliminary budget for next year. The funding source totals $752.3 million and does not include a tax increase. 

The district must pass the budget by the end of the month.

The deficit comes amid years of financial struggles for the district, something that is expected to continue in the near future. By 2026 the district is projecting a $23.1 million deficit. And, by 2027, a projected $26.3 million deficit would drop the fund balance to a negative $19.4 million.

Advertise with us

To help manage the growing costs —  and in response to decreasing enrollments — Pittsburgh Public is considering closing 14 schools and reconfiguring the class structure at 12 others.

But if the district had the additional money currently diverted to the city, discussions might not be so urgent. 

“The budgetary issues are a significant part of that … but the enrollment and our ability to provide high quality student outcomes is even more important,” Mr. Walker said. “So I think we’d probably still have that conversation, but we may not be looking at quite the scale that we are now.”

Even if the money couldn’t keep more of the schools open, it could help modernize the ones that will remain open, Mr. Weiss said. 

“This is money that should be spent on the children and families of the district, and not by the city on whatever they’re doing,” he said. 

Advertise with us

A few years after the diversion began, the district was designated a Commonwealth Partnership District and as a result, the district gets $8 million a year from the state. At first, it was enough to cover the funds being diverted to the city, but over time as income rates have increased, that $8 million “hasn’t kept up,” Mr. Weiss said.

Since 2012, the city has received about $250 million from the diversion, Mr. Weiss said. At the same time, the district has received about $96 million, which leaves the district about $154 million short. 

For now, the district is stuck in its current situation. According to Mr. Walker, any changes would have to come from the state House and Senate rewriting the document to phase the diversion out. 

Mr. Walker said he, Superintendent Wayne Walters and school director Devon Taliaferro went to Harrisburg earlier this year to talk to state lawmakers about the issue. During the meeting two solutions were presented: get legislation introduced that phases the diversion out over time. The other suggestion included increasing state funding to the district to help account for what is given to the city. But so far, neither plan has seen movement. 

The city, Mr. Walker said, has not indicated they want to change the current legislation. That’s on par with past conversations regarding the money. Former Pittsburgh Mayor Bill Peduto in 2019 while suggesting the district should go under state financial oversight denied the revenue should be rerouted back to PPS because it was diverted to the city during a financial restructuring.

Advertise with us

Instead, Mr. Peduto said the district should cut spending.

“But if they’re simply saying ‘we’re going to take your revenue,’ and not be the leaders that they were elected to be, and making tough decisions like raising taxes, then I have no time for that,” Mr. Peduto said at the time. “And I will fight them in Harrisburg.”

The city, while not facing a budget deficit now, is looking at lean years ahead in terms of revenue. By September of this year, the city’s revenues were about $15 million behind what they had projected at the beginning of the year. City coffers have been hit hard by the decrease in property taxes as a result of reassessments of Downtown’s largest buildings and remains in a legal battle over the collection of the so-called “jock tax.” 

"Until there is a reassessment to stabilize real estate tax revenue for jurisdictions across the County, continuing the diversion is necessary for the City to maintain a balanced budget in light of declining Real Estate Tax revenue driven by the Common Level Ratio decision,” Olga George, the mayor’s press secretary, said in a statement. 

Mr. Weiss compared the situation to an “old cliche.”

Advertise with us

“Anyone who proposes to rob Peter to pay Paul will always have the support of Paul,” he said. “That’s what this is. It’s ridiculous.” 

Change at the local level?

For now, the district is considering changes that could be made on the local level. 

Those include having local residents impacted by the diversion challenge the legislation in a lawsuit. Mr. Walker pointed to those living in Mt. Oliver, which is not part of the city but their school-age children attend the city schools. Those residents, he said, “don’t necessarily benefit from the services of the city so their tax money that should go to education, some of that is getting diverted to fund a municipality that they don’t live in.” 

The city of Pittsburgh does provide trash pickup for Mt. Oliver and frequently sends emergency services such as fire or police to calls from Mt. Oliver residents. Since 2012, Mt. Oliver residents alone have paid about $1.4 million to the city, according to Mr. Weiss. 

Additionally, Mr. Weiss believes most people that pay this tax to the city, including those that live in Mt. Oliver, are unaware of it. 

Advertise with us

“I would venture to say if you surveyed 5,000 families in the city, unless you were really lucky, no one would know anything about this,” he said. “If I had children in the district, I would not be happy about this.” 

As for school directors, they plan to continue lobbying state representatives for a solution.

“If we get a groundswell of folks who care about education to a point where they're like, ‘Hey, this doesn't make any sense that our kids are suffering because there was legislation that was written that should have been done differently.’ If they want to take up that fight I think that would help,” Mr. Walker said. “But I think it's a long road.”

Correction, posted Dec. 9, 2024: The spelling of the word “statute” has been fixed.