Hundreds of thousands of revelers are expected to pour into Downtown Pittsburgh on Saturday for the city’s massive St. Patrick’s Day parade, and huge crowds will likely spill into other pockets of the city for daylong events.

Shootings at a parade in Kansas City last month and at a Philadelphia bus stop last week give pause and pose the question: How do the city’s public safety branches keep the mass of visitors safe?

Planning is key, said emergency management coordinator Chief Darryl Jones.

“I cannot stop a shooting from happening,” Chief Jones said. “But we can be prepared to respond to it as fast as possible.”

Advertise with us

St. Patrick’s Day festivities essentially kick off a spring and summer of big, outdoor events across Pittsburgh. Marathon weekend is seven weeks away, followed by Pride, the Arts Festival, Fourth of July, Picklesburgh and more.

Planning for each doesn’t start from scratch each time; rather, the public safety surrounding each event follows the same framework. In Pittsburgh, public safety personnel use a plan called the National Incident Management System.

The keys to each plan involve setting objectives. In almost every case, Chief Jones said, the main objective will be to keep employees, residents and visitors safe.

“The nature of the event has a lot to do with what our priorities are,” the chief said, “but no matter what, safety is across the board.”

Planning for St. Patrick’s Day celebrations in Pittsburgh is unique in that festivities are spread across the city. Public safety staff — police, medics, fire crews, public works employees — will focus on three main areas: Downtown, the North Shore, and the South Side.

Advertise with us

Each area draws a different kind of crowd, and the type of crowd dictates how long people will hang around. For example, Market Square will host activities geared toward families and children. Officials expect Downtown will start to clear out soon after the parade ends. The crowd on the South Side, on the other hand, will likely grow as the day goes on and remain a draw until the bars close.

That means different concerns than other events, like the marathon. During marathon weekend, for example, EMS concerns center around heat-driven illnesses, cardiac issues and other running-related injuries. On Saturday, alcohol-related incidents and accidents will be among the main concerns.

“We might have somebody who drinks too much and gets sick, or people get beer muscles and become violent. People lose their sense of orientation and walk in front of a car,” Chief Jones said.

Planning starts two or three months in advance, and that usually involves getting a representative from each entity involved into the same room. That means it’s not just Pittsburgh police, fire and EMS in the room, but Allegheny County Police, state police, sheriff’s deputies, public works employees and state park rangers.

The point is to get specifics ironed out early, said Cmdr. Wanda Duncan.

Advertise with us

“From there we go about logistically planning these things: OK, what does this look like with traffic? What does this look like as far as having more people in this area? Can we safely do this with the number of people expected?” she said.

She echoed Chief Jones: “We don’t recreate the wheel if we don’t have to, so things that have been successful, we keep those in the plan.”

And when they find a new thing that works — or see one that worked in another city — they add that to the future plans. It’s not uncommon for public safety leaders to reach out to their counterparts in other cities.

“We will reach out to them and say, ‘Hey, what did you guys learn that we can now take here?’” she said.

Among Cmdr. Duncan’s duties on Saturday will be to make sure everyone is where they need to be. All information travels through her, be it from K-9 officers amidst the crowd, officers in the parade staging area, officers along the route or officers watching city camera feeds. She’ll make sure that information gets to the people it needs to get to — and only those people.

Advertise with us

“Is there something we need to be concerned about way at the end of the route? I’m not going to concern those officers at the beginning of the route because it doesn’t affect them,” she said. “But I am going to make sure everybody downrange knows, hey, this is what you have.”

Those duties remain mostly static for any incident commander during any event.

The coordinated effort happens at the city’s Office of Emergency Management and Homeland Security, a nondescript building along Railroad Street in the Strip District. The command center looks like most conference rooms, except a little bigger and with a few more televisions on the walls.

The centralized command location means that officials from every group involved — fire, city police, state police, EMS — can be in the same room and get the same information at the same time. If a particular intersection needs to be closed, no one has to contact public works employees to coordinate more saw horses — a public works employee is already in the room and already knows the situation. If more state troopers are needed somewhere, a state trooper is already in the room and can make those arrangements without an extra layer of communication.

That process has changed over the years as the work keeping events safe has moved from a strictly police-centric job to one that includes all components, from having medics stationed throughout the city to have firefighters doing occupancy checks at South Side bars.

Advertise with us

“It used to be that we didn’t come together, and what I mean is that we didn’t communicate very well between the bureaus to … collaborate with each other. Everybody was in their own little silos,” Chief Jones said. “What we’ve been working on is to make sure that we communicate with each other and that we cross pollinate among the silos.

“That way there’s no duplication of effort, and fewer things slip through the cracks,” he said.

‘Plan for the worst’

The city’s public safety personnel plan for all the scenarios they can but the truth remains that proactivity can only go so far.

“We are beyond diligent in the planning stages,” said police Chief Larry Scirotto. “You hope for the best and plan for the worst, and we take that into real practice.”

The variables are endless, and some are beyond anyone’s control. One of the televisions at the emergency operations center on Saturday will be tuned to the Weather Channel.

Advertise with us

“So St. Patrick’s Day, I don’t think anything’s going to stop [people from going out] — it’s not going to happen,” Chief Jones said. “The marathon is coming up the first weekend in May, and the cooler the weather, the less heat casualties we have to deal with and manage. On the flip side of that, if you have a concert like Kenny Chesney and people are sitting [in the stadium] and you have a pop-up storm … then you’re trying to shelter 80,000 people.”

And it’s impossible to plan for every element of human behavior.

Chief Jones pointed to the incident in Kansas City. One person was killed and dozens were injured. It was a mass shooting, but the circumstances weren’t those that the country has come to associate with mass shootings: This wasn’t one person trying to make a statement or killing people to get attention, the chief noted, and it wasn’t about killing a certain group of people out of hatred.

“These two clowns, they got in a fight and instead of taking it out with their fists, they both had guns,” he said. “And there you go.”

He continued: “Can it happen here? Yes. Will it happen here? I hope not. Can I prevent it? No.”

Advertise with us

There are proactive measures: There will be undercover officers among the crowds watching for signs a fight might be brewing and intelligence analysts watching social media for threats or any indications that beefs between groups could come to a deadly head.

Paramedics will be stationed around the city in ambulances, on bike and on motorcycle, Chief Jones said. Fire crews will enforce occupancy limits at bars “so if someone does start something in a bar, no one gets trampled and everyone can get out.

“There are just so many different [scenarios] that we try to do our best to prepare for,” he said.

That kind of preparation is the best defense at these kinds of large-scale events, according to Adam Bercovici, a retired Los Angeles Police Department lieutenant and former security company owner.

“They’re not impossible to police, but you have to have the right amount of officers or security professionals or a combination of officers and security professionals,” he said. “You have to have good coordinated efforts, and a unified command is really important.”

Advertise with us

Metal-detecting or searching hundreds of thousands of people who pour into open events like the Kansas City Super Bowl parade or Pittsburgh’s St. Patrick’s Day parade just isn’t possible, Mr. Bercovici said. But doing away with those events because of the world we live in also isn’t an option.

“People are still going to want to celebrate. People are still going to be foolish, and some people are going to not obey the rules,” he said.

Chief Scirotto said that what happened in Kansas City wasn’t because of a lack of policing.

“And then this intersection of people in a place that doesn’t have an officer standing on the corner is the place of violence,” he said. “We have a lot of resources. We overload on resources and just hope that that level of visibility is the deterrent for something like that.”