More than 100 students and demonstrators gathered at Carnegie Mellon University’s “Walking to The Sky” statue Thursday afternoon to call for a cease-fire in Gaza, where Palestinian officials said at least 10,800 have been killed by Israel in response to a cross-border Hamas raid last month.
Some demonstrators arrived draped in Palestinian flags and others showed up waving signs that read “End all U.S. aid to apartheid Israel,” “Resistance is not terrorism,” and “When people are occupied, resistance is justified” at the rally hosted by Students for Justice in Palestine at the University of Pittsburgh and other student-led groups.
Shortly before the demonstration was set to take place, Carnegie Mellon University released a statement on the X platform, formerly known as Twitter, saying that it had just learned of the planned rally that was being promoted on social media.
The university said the event was not approved to take place on campus because none of the organizing groups came forward to officially serve as sponsors, although the demonstration was ultimately still allowed to take place by campus police, who were on scene.
As students began to congregate around the statue, they were also met with opposition from a passerby, who shouted “Why don’t you guys go back to Gaza” at the swelling crowd before walking away.
As the event kicked off, a University of Pittsburgh student who identified himself as Muhammad Ali led demonstrators in 10 minutes of chants that included calls of “Liberation for the oppressed,” “Abolish imperialism,” and “Free free Palestine.”
Mr. Ali, who later declined to speak with the Post-Gazette, then handed the mic over to a series of speakers that included Leo Deng, a junior philosophy student at CMU and co-founder of the Carnegie Mellon College Progressives, who condemned those in the academic community who have not voiced their support for the Palestinians.
“What other purpose than fetishing your own intellectualism do you have for not applying your studies to real life, especially when people need it most right now,” Mr. Deng said, which was met with cheers by the crowd.
Another speaker, Deena Eldaour, a Pitt student born and raised in Pittsburgh who said she has family in Gaza, said her relatives have been killed in the conflict and recounted conversations she had with her friends in the war-torn area.
“Ever since the war started, I’ve lost 20 of my family members,” Ms. Eldaour said. “So I think it’s really important that people like me can go out and speak up against what’s been happening.”
Not everyone who showed up was on the same side of the issue.
As the rally carried on, a small group of counter-protesters gathered toward the outskirts of the demonstration that included a man who began screaming “return the hostages you cowards” until he was confronted by campus police.
“I just think it’s unacceptable what’s been going on on campuses and generally what’s been going on around the country right now,” said the man, who identified himself as John but declined to provide his last name. “I think the people here are very misguided and I think what is happening is frankly disgusting.”
John said he decided to challenge the protesters after he became enraged by their chant: “From the River to the Sea, Palestine will be free,” a charged phrase branded antisemitic by the Anti-Defamation League.
“I just can’t stand by and not call them out for what they’re saying,” he said.
Despite the tense, but brief, exchange, the rally carried on and remained peaceful.
And while the crowd was made up primarily of students, others who showed up to call for Middle East peace included a pair of Pittsburgh public school teachers, one who is still teaching and another who is retired.
“Without a cease-fire it really looks like Israel is committing genocide, an ethnic cleansing and the people of Palestine desperately need a cease-fire,” Kate Daher, a 72-year-old retired school teacher, said. “The reason I’m here is because, like millions of people across the world, we need to see a cease-fire.”
Erin Breault, 63, who is currently teaching in city schools, pointed to an incident at Allderdice High School in which a wall was graffitied “Free Palestine,” an act of vandalism the school condemned as antisemitic.
“That’s silencing a speech that the students at that school wanted to get out,” she said.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.