A new analysis of Pittsburgh police staffing suggests that the budgeted number of officers is sufficient, though the department needs some restructuring. But some police and other officials were hesitant Wednesday to follow the recommendations laid out by the long-awaited study.
The city budgets for 900 officers, but has been far below that number for quite some time, prompting concern from local officials.
“The 900 budgeted is a good amount of officers for us to have,” Public Safety Director Lee Schmidt said in releasing the study, which was commissioned by the city last year. “It's a matter of where those officers are placed and how they're utilized that we need to take a look at.”
As of Wednesday morning, there were 792 officers. A new recruit class is scheduled to start Monday with 30 new trainees. Another is scheduled for sometime in November with “up to 40” recruits, police Chief Larry Scirotto said.
“The staffing levels that we have aren’t in crisis,” Chief Scirotto said during a news conference at the police headquarters. “The current staffing that we have, keeps the city very safe on a daily basis.”
Among other things, the study recommended re-deploying some patrol officers to different units. The study, which the city commissioned for $180,000 last year, was conducted by the San Francisco-based Matrix Consulting Group.
Chief Scirotto, who was confirmed as the new department head in May, called the study a “great document,” especially for a new chief.
“It provides the foundation for how I’ll move the bureau forward, in that this blueprint is a recommendation, it’s not a directive,” he said. “It gives me the ability to allocate our resources in an appropriate manner.”
The study also provides an “outside perspective” on the department’s operations, he said. “It gives me the ability to stand in front of the men or women that represent the Pittsburgh bureau of police and tell them why we're doing these things.”
Bob Swartzwelder, the president of the local police union, greeted the study more warily.
“Either this study is invalid, or command is severely mismanaging its police force,” he said. “If we’re properly staffed, why are officers routinely being compelled for overtime.”
Mr. Swartzwelder said that between Tuesday and 7 a.m. Wednesday, 22 officers were held for mandatory overtime.
Mr. Scirotto on Wednesday said that overtime was being mandated not because there weren’t enough officers, but “because we don’t have our resources allocated in the appropriate places.”
The study also suggests there are “several opportunities” for jobs being done by officers to be performed instead by civilians, Chief Scirotto said, which would then free up officers for other work.
“When I talk about civilianization it’s not in place of our officers,” Chief Scirotto said. “It’s to complement our officers.”
And the study suggested that more officers be reallocated to the Violent Crimes Unit because of “high caseloads.”
Part of the study analyzed police response times and ranked the bureau’s as “exceptional.” It also measured “proactive time,” or the time that officers are not responding to calls. Agencies typically strive for 40% proactive time. Pittsburgh’s, based on data from 2021, was at 71%, indicating “exceptionally high levels of service,” the report said.
But it also said Pittsburgh’s 71% proactive time was “excessively high — far beyond the point at which there is appreciable value gained from additional coverage.” Because of that, it recommended that Pittsburgh reduce its patrol officers by 188 positions and reallocate some of them into a Community Resource Officer program.
Chief Scirotto pushed back on the idea of reducing patrol officers to create a special community-oriented program.
“I don’t want to reallocate any patrol officers,” he said. “I am of the belief that all 900 men and women are community oriented police officers.”
In a meeting with City Council in May, the new police chief stressed his desire to make sure every officer was actively involved in the community, rather than a set group being assigned to community engagement.
“When we create these units, it says to the rest of the rank and file that [community engagement] is not their responsibility,” he said at the time. “They should all be community resource offices.
Despite the report’s finding that there are excessive amounts of proactive time, officers seemed to feel differently.
In the officer survey portion of the report, about 85% of the more than 560 officers interviewed said they either disagreed or strongly disagreed with the statement, “We have sufficient proactive time available to address problems in the community.”
In those surveys, 60% of the officers interviewed either disagreed or strongly disagreed that their schedules allowed for an “adequate work life balance.”
The report also made recommendations for how many patrol officers each of the department’s six zones should have. All of the zone recommendations include a reduction in officers from current staffing levels, Mr. Swartzwelder said.
“I would be hesitant to decrease the number of officers assigned to the zones because people complain that there aren’t enough officers as it is,” said Beth Pittinger, the executive director of the Citizen Police Review Board.
Brian Vetere, co-owner of the Carson City Saloon on East Carson Street — which has temporarily closed because of recent shootings and public safety concerns — said the South Side doesn't have enough officers on patrol.
Before the pandemic, there used to be upwards of 30 cops patrolling the South Side and nearby areas, Mr. Vetere said. Before last weekend — when the city and the Allegheny County Sheriff's office sent more officers to address recent concerns — business owners were lucky to see four or five officers on the South Side, he said.
Zone 3, which includes the South Side, currently has 59 officers assigned to it, Mr. Swartzwelder said. The study suggested lowering that to 49.
Mr. Scirotto didn’t say whether the city would follow those recommendations The study based those numbers on call volumes, but not the crimes the calls were made for, Chief Scirotto said.
“There are some zones that have high call volumes, but don’t have high instances of violent crime,” he said. “We have to ensure that the calls that require intense police response have the personnel to support it.”
Earlier this year, after a string of crime Downtown, Mayor Ed Gainey pledged more officers to the area.
Ms. Pittinger said she was concerned about some of the recommendations, like removing patrol officers. But what really stuck out to her was the lack of community involvement.
“It’s purely data analysis,” she said. “And it certainly has a value, but I think it has to be coupled with community expectations and community feedback on how our service is being delivered.”
“I hope there’s value in this [survey] for Scirotto and his team,” Ms. Pittinger added. “This is not a blueprint for improving the city of Pittsburgh Bureau of Police. It’s information, and it’s very thorough comprehensive information, but I would be very hesitant to take it as ‘okay now this is what we’re going to implement.’”
Staff writer Steve Bohnel contributed.
Hallie Lauer: hlauer@post-gazette.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.