It’s perhaps the most consequential question levied in the trial against Pittsburgh synagogue shooter Robert Bowers.
Should he be put to death for his crimes?

For more than four years, it’s the question that has drawn vastly different reactions from the Pittsburgh community and the three distinct congregations who lost members in the synagogue massacre.
At a Tuesday news conference, Rabbi Dr. Danny Schiff of the Jewish Federation of Greater Pittsburgh said that, ultimately, the Jewish faith’s guiding texts permit the death penalty in the most heinous of crimes.
But those extreme circumstances that justify the punishment? That’s something today’s Jewish community, from worshippers to rabbis, continue to differ on, he said.
“It’s well known the Jewish tradition is a faith-based system, but it's also based in a legal system,” Rabbi Schiff said. “It's perfectly possible for a legal system to yield more than one viewpoint which is acceptable.”
Read More
The discussion came two days into the penalty phase of the trial against Bowers. A jury on June 16 found him guilty on 63 federal charges in the deaths of 11 worshippers at the Tree of Life synagogue in Squirrel Hill on Oct. 27, 2018: Joyce Fienberg, Richard Gottfried, Rose Mallinger, Jerry Rabinowitz, Cecil and David Rosenthal, Bernice and Sylvan Simon, Daniel Stein, Melvin Wax, Irving Younger.
Three congregations worshipped in the synagogue at the corner of Shady and Wilkins avenues: Tree of Life, Dor Hadash and New Light.
Rabbi Schiff said the Torah, a foundational Jewish text, appears to leave little interpretation when it comes to capital punishment. Unequivocally, the text, he said, accepts capital punishment as a possibility.
“Every single book of the Torah really advocates or instructs that consideration be given to the possibility of applying the death penalty in certain circumstances,” he said.
But what is distinctive about the Jewish tradition, he said, is that the guidance doesn’t end with the Torah. The oral Torah makes the application of the death penalty “exceedingly hard” to do, as it outlines many prerequisites and safeguards that ensure the punishment aligns with a “Jewish sense of justice.” The Talmud outlines a stringent system of justice, too.
“The death penalty should be a possibility for those particular moments when society is confronted with an example of ultimate evil, but it shouldn't be something that is used with any frequency to the contrary, it should be exceedingly rare even if the society is met with heinous acts,” Rabbi Schiff said.
One text often quoted, he said, is that the death penalty, if applied once in 70 years, would be violent or excessive.
Translating these principles in a modern world is a “complex act of translation” that people of the faith continue to tackle, he said. The system of justice outlined in the Talmud makes such requirements that a major court of 23 ordained judges be used to sentence a man to death, for example. In Bowers' case, there are 12 deliberating jurors and 5 alternates.
The rules outlined in the Talmud cannot be replicated exactly anymore, the rabbi said, and Jewish people — whether Orthodox or Reformed — come to their own individual conclusions.
“Consequently, it is perfectly plausible for Jews to differ on the question of when and if the death penalty should actually be employed,” he said. “Rabbis differ on this question.”
In the aftermath of synagogue shooting, some in the Jewish community have supported a deal for life without parole for Bowers, including Dor Hadash congregants who have cited religious and personal objections. Opposingly, seven of the nine families who lost loved ones have maintained their support for the death penalty, as evidenced in a 2021 letter to Attorney General Merrick Garland.
For Rabbi Schiff, though Jewish people can’t apply old rules to the modern justice system, it’s about striving to meet the underlying ethos of the principles.
“What we can do is draw on the ethos of that material and try to evaluate, given the way in which they approached the subject, how would they have us approach this particular area in our day and age and try to take the spirit and apply it appropriately in our contemporary circumstances?” he said.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.