Lesions on the inner portions of convicted synagogue shooter Robert Bowers’ brain could be indicative of epilepsy, schizophrenia or some sort of brain damage, two experts testified Tuesday.
Those lesions could also be indicative of heavy smoking or hypertension, the same experts said.

Defense attorneys for Bowers, who could face the death penalty for gunning down 11 Jewish congregants at a Squirrel Hill synagogue in 2018, began building their case for jurors to spare their client’s life with extensive testimony as to his brain, its functioning, and its alleged abnormalities.
Bowers, 50, was convicted June 16 of 63 federal charges related to the Oct. 27, 2018, mass shooting at a synagogue that housed three congregations: Tree of Life, Dor Hadash and New Light. Eleven worshippers were killed: Richard Gottfried, Joyce Fienberg, Rose Mallinger, Jerry Rabinowitz, Cecil and David Rosenthal, Bernice and Sylvan Simon, Daniel Stein, Melvin Wax, Irving Younger.
Dr. Andrew Newberg, a physician of nuclear medicine in Philadelphia, also testified that he noted abnormalities in Bowers’ PET scan. The scans, called positron emission tomography scans, measure blood flow and glucose processing to produce three-dimensional images. In this case, it was of Bowers’ brain.
He said the abnormalities he observed in the scan, which was done in late 2021, indicated an overactive frontal lobe, which can be caused by inflammation. That can lead to a “persistently excited state,” he said.
Read More
He also noted abnormalities the metabolism in various areas in Bowers’ brain, including in the left medial temporal lobe. That, Dr. Newberg said, can be associated with issues related to memory and abstract reasoning. It can also cause delusions — including religious delusions.
U.S. Attorney Eric Olshan asked the doctor if he was testifying that a person whose brain generated the PET scan he analyzed was incapable of forming the intent to kill another person.
“I don’t think that can be answered on the basis of a PET scan,” Dr. Newberg said. Pressed by Mr. Olshan, he said that a PET scan can’t be used to diagnose anything on its own.
Tuesday marked the second day of testimony in the penalty phase of the trial, where 12 jurors and 5 alternates will determine whether his crimes qualify him for the death penalty and, if so, whether he should receive it.
Dr. Murray Solomon, a neuroradiologist and the medical director of the Bay Area MRI Medical Partnership in Los Gatos, Calif., said he reviewed an MRI of Bowers performed by a UPMC facility in early 2022.
His review revealed 28 white matter lesions. Gray matter, he explained, makes up the surface of the brain where the actual processing is done, whereas white matter is where the brain’s proverbial wiring is. In essence, white matter helps the different parts of the brain communicate with each other.
Those white matter lesions represent permanent scars, Dr. Solomon said, and the underlying brain is dead.
“These lesions are everywhere throughout the brain, throughout the hemispheres,” he said, calling it a “very large number of lesions” for, at the time, a 49-year-old male. That’s compared to a database of “normal” brain scans, he said.
The lesions, he said, could be caused by a traumatic brain injury or other brain abnormalities, and they could generate epilepsy. He said he also noted a significant difference in size between Bowers’ right hippocampus and left hippocampus. That could indicate brain damage, he said.
Dr. Solomon said he had no real background on Bowers when he analyzed the MRI.
Mr. Olshan presented the doctor — who testified via video-conferencing — with a photo from inside Bowers’ Baldwin apartment. The photo shows pipe tobacco and a box of rolling papers.
Defense attorneys for Bowers revealed earlier this year they intended to present evidence of epilepsy and schizophrenia as part of their case during the sentencing phase of the trial, though not as a defense against guilt.
Mr. Olshan pointed out that Dr. Solomon’s report on Bowers’ MRI scan doesn’t mention schizophrenia. Dr. Solomon said he didn’t know that schizophrenia could cause white matter lesions until he was reviewing other expert reports in the Bowers case. Then, he said, he Googled it.
Mr. Olshan was incredulous. Dr. Solomon explained that he can access academic journals via Google.
Also on Tuesday, three Pittsburgh-based brain-imaging experts testified that Bowers was presented to them with a clinical diagnosis of epilepsy in late 2021, though none could point to any truly conclusive evidence from Bowers’ brain scans that could back up that diagnosis.
That doesn’t mean he doesn’t have epilepsy, each said.
Bowers’ defense team began building its case against the death penalty with its first three witnesses as the trial winds its way through the so-called eligibility phase.
Defense attorney Michael Burt first called Dr. Vijayalakshmi Rajasekaran, a neurologist who is the director of UPMC Presbyterian’s EEG lab. An EEG, which stands for electroencephalogram, is a scan that measures the electrical activity of the brain.
While she did not perform the EEG, she did examine and interpret the results, she testified.
She said the EEG of Bowers — in which his brain activity was collected over 48 hours — showed a slowing of brain waves that were “sharply contoured.” That type of pattern can be, but isn’t always, indicative of a patient who could experience seizures.
Over the course of the two days of brain wave collection, Dr. Rajasekaran said, the test did not capture any evidence of an actual seizure. She said the EEG wouldn’t tell her about a patient’s potential to have a seizure.
UPMC neuroradiologist Dr. Joseph Mettenburg also testified as to Bowers’ MRI, also noting what he called “white-matter hyperintensities.” Otherwise, he said, it was “a normal brain MRI.”
The defense team will resume calling witnesses on Wednesday morning.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.