Relatives of two victims of the Tree of Life synagogue shooting voiced their support Friday afternoon for the death penalty ahead of the trial for the accused gunman.

Diane and Michele Rosenthal, sisters of Cecil and David Rosenthal, said it wasn’t the family’s intention to talk about legal proceedings ahead of the April 24 trial start, but they felt compelled to “speak up” and clarify their views.

“We don't want to be here and we know the emotional toll this trial potentially brings. But we owe it to our brothers Cecil and David,” Diane Rosenthal said. “The suggestion that all the family members of the deceased victims do not wish to proceed with a death penalty case is false.”

Robert Bowers is accused of gunning down 11 worshippers on Oct. 27, 2018 at the Tree of Life synagogue, a hulking stone building at the intersection of Wilkins and Shady avenues. The building housed three congregations — Dor Hadash, New Light and Tree of Life / Or L’Simcha. The latter congregation owned the building, and its name is written in English and Hebrew on the north wall.

Advertise with us

“Tree of Life” became the grim moniker for the massacre, and the Jewish congregants killed there became the faces of the nation’s worst anti-Semitic attack: Richard Gottfried, Joyce Fienberg, Rose Mallinger, Jerry Rabinowitz, David and Cecil Rosenthal, Bernice and Sylvan Simon, Daniel Stein, Melvin Wax, Irving Younger.

Diane Rosenthal said the family’s position has not changed and that opposing views to the death penalty have “come from individuals of the congregations, elected officials and others who think they know what's best for the families.”

Read More

“The suggestions published or reported that family members be relieved of the stress of a trial or that a cost benefit analysis dictates a plea are offensive to our family,” Diane Rosenthal said. “This plays right into the hands of the ongoing transparent strategy by the defense to delay in hopes of achieving this result.” 

Some of the victims’ families have supported a deal for life without parole for Mr. Bowers while others have vocalized their strong support for the death penalty. 

Members of Congregation Dor Hadash and New Light had previously asked the federal government to forgo a trial and allow Mr. Bowers to plead guilty in exchange for life in prison.

Advertise with us

In a 2019 letter to the Justice Department, New Light congregants cited religious and personal objections to capital punishment. They also pointed to how traumatic a trial would be for victims’ families.

New Light Rabbi Johnathan Perlman wrote that he would like to see Mr. Bowers imprisoned for life.

“He should meditate on whether taking action on some white separatist fantasy against the Jewish people was really worth it,” Rabbi Perlman wrote in his Aug. 1, 2019 letter. “Let him live with it forever. I am mainly interested in not letting this thug cause my community any further pain.”

Donna Coufal, of Dor Hadash, said in her 2019 letter to the Justice Department that a trial will just add to Mr. Bowers’ publicity.

“A plea bargain for life without parole will prevent this individual getting the attention and publicity that would inevitably come with a trial,” she wrote.

Advertise with us

Miri Rabinowitz, the widow of Dor Hadash congregant Dr. Jerry Rabinowitz, sent her own letter and asked then-Attorney General William Barr to accept a plea deal in honor of her late husband and “his deep and abiding opposition to the death penalty.”

She wrote: “This conclusion to the federal prosecution would permit me to continue the slow and painful process of healing without having to relive the horrific circumstances of Jerry’s murder through a trial and inevitable lengthy appeals and deny the perpetrator a public platform from which to spew his most vicious, and sadly infectious brand of hatred.”

Members of Dor Hadash issued their plea again in 2021, this time to Attorney General Merrick Garland.

Michele Rosenthal said that of the 63 criminal counts Mr. Bowers is facing, 22 are considered death penalty-eligible. Each of those counts corresponds to one of the 11 victims.

She said the family has suffered “long and hard” over the last four years and do not want to continue defending their position. Rather, they want to see justice, she said. 

“This massacre was not just a mass murder of innocent citizens during the service in a house of worship,” she said. “It was an anti-Semitic hate crime. The death penalty must apply to vindicate justice and to offer some measure of deterrence from horrific hate crimes happening again and again.”