Larry Scirotto plans to retool and reimagine the police department where he’s already spent most of his career.

But for the man next in line to lead the Pittsburgh Bureau of Police, that doesn’t mean starting from scratch. Many of his ideas come from what’s already proven to work in reducing violence and crime in the city. Some of them are strategies he used as major crimes commander, during his first stint with Pittsburgh police from 1995 to 2018.

“I don’t suggest for a moment that law enforcement needs to reinvent any wheels. We have seen successful strategies in the past work here,” Mr. Scirotto, who could be confirmed as the city’s new top cop as early as Tuesday, told the Post-Gazette last week. “Now you retool it, and you make it the mission and the direction of the organization — and everyone within the organization — [to prioritize] violence reduction and, most importantly, gun violence reduction.”

In a wide-ranging interview Thursday that directly followed an hours-long session before City Council, Mr. Scirotto talked about building relationships, violence reduction, the police calls that eat up tens of thousands of personnel hours each year, and the best Italian food in the city (Alla Famiglia in Allentown, he said).

Advertise with us
New Acting Pittsburgh police Chief Larry Scirotto on Thursday at police headquarters. (Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Pittsburgh Mayor Ed Gainey nominated Mr. Scirotto earlier this month, and he’s serving as acting chief until Council approves his appointment.

His goals aren’t new ones: The main job of police should be protecting the city, not chasing parking complaints and false burglar alarms, he said. They should be guardians, not warriors, and they should be out in the community all the time, not just in times of crisis. And police officers themselves should be the face of the department when it comes to badly needed recruiting.

Mr. Scirotto, 49, takes over a bureau that’s just barely hovering above 800 officers — 100 short of its full budgeted complement.

Bringing officer ranks back to 900 will take some time, Mr. Scirotto said. In the meantime, there are ways to refocus police attention on stemming the violence.

For example: The highest number of complaints Pittsburgh police received last year?

Advertise with us

Parking complaints. Ten thousand of them.

And it’s takes about 45 minutes from the time a call comes in to when an officer responds and then is back in service, he said.

“We spent 45,000 man hours a year on parking complaints,” Mr. Scirotto said.

He’s incredulous on that point: “My challenge to [City Council] is, is that the kind of policing function you want with the 806 officers that I have available to me and at my disposal?”

The second-highest category of calls was burglar alarms. Some 99% of the roughly 7,000 of them, he said, were false alarms. But two police cars must respond to each alarm, and it takes about 30 minutes to finish that job. That’s another 70,000 hours eaten up by what are largely non-criminal calls.

Advertise with us

“It’s unconscionable in 2023 that a police department this size doesn’t offer its citizens the ability to report theft, criminal mischief [online],” he said.

Getting some of that time back could help with recruitment issues and shift the focus to more pressing crime.

“What if I told you we’re going to spend 50,000 personnel hours on community-police partnerships, community engagement, quality of life?” he said. “What if I say we’re going to take the other 70,000 hours and I’ll put them to our violent crime reduction strategy, specifically gun violence?

“How much better would we be serving our community?”

Earning community trust

Violent crimes – specifically gun crime — is lower right now than it was at this point last year, he said. While perception is often different, he said, the data shouldn’t be brushed off.

Advertise with us

“Those numbers are real,” he said. Those are human beings that are not dead, and those are people that are not being shot.”

His goal is to build on that.

New Acting Pittsburgh police Chief Larry Scirotto on Thursday at police headquarters. (Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Mr. Scirotto helped develop and lead the strategies put into place when he was a unit commander in 2014, a year that saw near-record homicides in the city. Five years later, the city had its safest year in more than two decades, something he touted as a direct result of the efforts that began in 2014.

But three years of a pandemic and changes in leadership meant the department began to move in a new direction, he said, and “violent crime reduction wasn’t the priority.”

“We have to show the community they should trust us to keep them safe,” he said. “When we talk about mistrust, it’s often to that point… do we trust the police to keep us safe?”

Advertise with us

“They have to believe that our motives are pure,” he added.

The city has for years had officers assigned to units specializing in community relations. That’s not enough, Mr. Scirotto said.

“If all of our officers are accessible, our officers are available, then those that will be responding in times of crisis will have the best opportunity to succeed,” he said. “When we make it a unit’s responsibility, well, that’s not the person that answers the call in the middle of the night.”

Reflecting the community

Less than 15% of officers are people of color. But Black residents alone make up about 23% of the city’s population.

“And we are moving further and further away [from mirroring the city racially] every day,” Mr. Scirotto said.

Advertise with us

He said there’s been no real recruitment strategy for years. Recruitment became a function of the city’s human resources department, something Mr. Scirotto said shouldn’t have happened.

“[Recruits] want to see or hear from people within the bureau that have those life experiences similar to theirs, and they want to know from people who wear the uniform what the experience is like — is it welcoming?” he said. “If you don’t have a recruiting strategy that goes into those underserved communities, we can’t say, ‘Oh, we’re welcoming — but come to us.’ We know that doesn’t happen. History tells us that doesn’t happen.”

Recruitment has fallen short in many ways, not just in diversifying officer ranks. A recruit class earlier this year meant to attract veteran police officers ended up with just three. Dozens of officers retired or resigned last year, and more than a dozen have so far this year.

Mr. Scirotto said some of that could and likely does go back to all of the responsibilities that have, by default, become a police problem.

New Acting Pittsburgh police Chief Larry Scirotto on Thursday at police headquarters. (Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

“When they start, they didn’t apply to [the] parking authority. They didn’t apply to go work for ADT,” he said. “We say we want you to have purpose, we want you to be engaged, but we don’t give you time to do either of those things.”

Advertise with us

Instead, Mr. Scirotto said, officers go from parking complaint to burglar alarm to theft report and back to a different parking complaint.

“Before you know it, you’ve done that two or three years in a row,” he said.

“I don’t for a moment suggest I’m taking these things away from them to do less work,” he added. “I’m just taking them away to do the things we say are more important, more police-centric.”