It was quiet when community members gathered at the Farmhouse Playground Tuesday morning in Highland Park to protest the Pittsburgh Police Department firing range. The sounds of gunshots fired by officers-in-training often heard in the area had already rang out earlier that morning.
Long frustrated by that gunfire and “broken promises” made by the city, the Highland Park Community Council held a news conference to reiterate their calls to shut down the range.
Stephanie Walsh, president of the Highland Park Community Council, opened the event with an audio clip playing the sounds of the gunfire off her phone. She said the clip was recorded last Friday morning about a half mile away from the park, just down the hill at another city playground.
“The gunfire noise is very loud and very unnerving,” she said. “And if it was actually happening right now you wouldn't be able to hear me speak.”
Since the 80s, she said residents have complained but nothing has been done. She said neighborhood residents and park users “respect” and “appreciate” city officers and understand the need for proper training – they just believe it shouldn’t be in earshot of neighborhoods and a large city park.
“We want them to have proper firearms training,” she said. “We don't view this as a police issue. We view it as a public health issue.”
Read More
In March, she said 19 weekdays out of 23 week days of the month, they had practice scheduled, including Sundays.
And given recent increases in gun violence and threats against schools, including two Pittsburgh Catholic schools, she said the noise triggers anxiety in both adults and children.
“When you hear it, in your heart, what you're thinking about is that it sounds like what a mass shooting would sound like,” she said.
She also discussed the plan previously proposed under former Mayor Bill Peduto to construct a large public safety facility at the former Veterans Affairs hospital campus which would replace the current range in Highland Park. After the city council moved roughly $1.4 million from the project, she wants to see action, even if it means finding another site for a range.
“We urge the mayor to recognize that being exposed to gunfire on a daily basis is not normal, that it is a public health concern and to find money in the current budget to begin a transparent planning process immediately for closing the firing range as soon as possible,” she said.
At the news conference, resident Joy Katz held a sign plastered with a printout of the petition she recently created. The petition reupped discussion about the gun range and has gathered nearly 1,200 signatures.
Emphasizing the noise’s health impacts, she also drew attention to the environmental concerns the range poses. In 2021, the city’s Department of Public Works said that runoff from the range was creating excess water on site and down to Washington Boulevard, contributing to flooding and erosion of land.
“We have concerns about the health of the soil and water on a site that was unpermitted and not designed to be a proper firing range,” she said.
Councilwoman Deb Gross joined residents for the conference. She did not speak during the event but in comments to reporters afterward, she affirmed that the range should be moved. But she also said the 200-acre facility proposed under Mr. Peduto was not necessary. She said that plan would take awhile and “frankly, may never happen.”
She also compared the proposal to Atlanta’s Cop City, a controversial plan for a $90 million police training center that has spurred months-long protests attesting that the center will further militarize the police.
“Those funds were about the massive 200 acre proposal under the Peduto administration for a combined public facing training facility that would be very akin to the Atlanta Cop City,” she said. “Most of the neighbors here did not support a 200 acre facility for public safety training, and we don't need 200 acres to have an indoor firing range.”
She said there are other alternate, more feasible plans that should be looked at, including creating a smaller indoor range, which she estimated would cost between $3 million and $15 million.
Highland Park resident Tim Tracy, carrying a sign reading, “Protect the Vulnerable, Protect Police Training,” brought a different view from other residents to the event. He says he hears the shots in his work as a contractor, as he works on public housing in nearby neighborhoods, but he doesn’t find it “particularly disruptive.”
He doubts a new facility is coming soon, so without alternatives on the table, he doesn’t want to see the range shut down.
“We need well supported and well trained police, and we should be doing everything that we can do in order to make it easier for our police to train and maintain their professional credentials,” he said. “The call is to close it without providing proper and peaceful alternatives.”
When it comes to a new facility or range, Highland Park resident Christy Stuber is not as worried about where it would be located, as long as it’s indoors.
Since plans are still being mulled, she wonders why sound mitigation measures haven’t been implemented, such as a wall to help block off the sound.
“In the meantime, are there ways to restructure the firing range?” she said. “What are we doing now that can remediate some of the noise? I’m really eager to work more with the mayor's office and figure out a solution.”
Tina Rhoades, who lives off Sheridan Avenue right near the park, also supports the idea of the proposed public safety facility as long as it’s enclosed. She’s lived in the neighborhood since 2010, and she estimates she hears the sounds about five days a week. At times, it’s up to six hours.
She hopes the new attention to this decades-long issue might ignite enough momentum to finally close the range.
“It's been something that's been requested for 40 years,” she said. “I realize funds are tight, but I think it should be given some priority. I don't think it's really anything against the police. It's the noise. It's the reduction of quality of life when you are living near the park.”




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.