The gunfire can sound off as early as 7 a.m. and as late as 9 p.m.  

It’s nonstop for hours, and consistent over days and weeks at a time. It comes in rapid succession or a few, isolated blasts. The pops of the shots are heard during morning jogs along the trail, dinnertime at home, walks with the dog along the reservoir and while children run on the playground. 

This is how Highland Park residents describe living near an open air firing range operated by the Pittsburgh Police Department.

A town hall attended by several city leaders last week, including Mayor Ed Gainey and Councilwoman Deb Gross, and a growing online petition have renewed attention to the decades-long controversy surrounding the range. Residents across the neighborhood say the constant gunfire is more than a nuisance — it’s a public health problem.

Advertise with us

Since the late 1980s, residents have voiced their disapproval of the range’s proximity to the Highland Park neighborhood and a major park of the same name, according to Stephanie Walsh, president of the Highland Park Community Council. 

The range, near the police academy training center, is on the eastern hillside above Washington Boulevard. 

While seemingly isolated in the woods, community members say training sessions held at the range for police recruits and officers brings audible, repetitive gunfire to large portions of Highland Park, even reaching surrounding neighborhoods such as Morningside, Stanton Heights and Aspinwall. 

HPCC created a firing range working group in 2021, which Ms. Walsh said includes Councilwoman Gross and other city leaders, to discuss ways to address the site. She said a variety of solutions have been put on the table, such as a new indoor facility, but she and other residents feel public leaders have been slow to take action.

“No one's really made a good faith effort to do anything,” she said.  “We know that, long term, closing it is going to take time. That can't happen overnight. But in the meantime, we still have this public health issue, and there are different steps that can be taken to mitigate the problem. There’s scheduling issues. There's some investments they could make in the space that don't involve totally rebuilding the site.”

Advertise with us

During a Tuesday town hall at Union Project last week, Mr. Gainey acknowledged early on that the range is a point of contention among community members. Mr. Gainey told attendees he doesn’t “have all the answers,” adding it’s not an “easy thing” to address, but his administration has been working on it. 

“I'm not going to be the mayor to come up here too and tell y'all, as previous mayors have done, we got it, we got it, we got it,” he said. “We can't have it if there's no plan. The reality is we're starting a plan to see how we can address it, and so I wanted to make sure I talked about that first because I know that's very important.”

Ms. Gross also briefly addressed the range at the top of the meeting before moving to a street speeding issue. 

About 20 minutes later, Joy Katz, a Highland Park resident of eight years, stood up to bring discussion back to the range. 

“Deb Gross said that the issue has been addressed at this meeting,” she said. “I don't feel that the issue has been addressed at this meeting. People are very affected by the sound of gunfire. I bet there is nobody in this room whose life is not somehow touched by gunfire. My neighbor had a 13 year old daughter who shot herself this past fall … That family woke up two days later to go bury her and walked out their front door into blasts from automatic weapons.”

Advertise with us

The office has looked for other alternative places to train, including a facility in Monroeville, but there wasn’t availability, according to Mr. Gainey. He also said they’ve investigated ways to make the gun noise quieter. 

Mr. Gainey and the Pittsburgh Police Department did not respond to requests for comment, and Ms. Gross declined to provide comment. 

Jake Pawlak, deputy mayor & director office of management and budget, said residents “are right” in that the answer is to move the range into an indoor enclosed facility, and plans are in the works. 

“In this year's capital budget we intend to fund such a project like that, to build a joint public safety training facility, including a range, that will solve this issue,” he said. “But it will take us a few years between when we started that work and when that project will be completed.”

In the meantime, Pawlak said his office has investigated ways to divert training time to other ranges but they are constrained by their hours of availability.

Advertise with us

Lee Schmidt, director of public safety, added only some units are permitted to use suppressors on their weapons in their training.

“They can't use them for all training, unfortunately, by state regulations and how they have to qualify,” Mr. Schmidt said. “It's the weapon they carry when they're on duty, which normally we don't have suppressors on them.”

Ms. Katz remembers not feeling satisfied with the answers to an issue she feels has long been ignored. 

“We just want the gunfire to stop now,” she said during the meeting. “It's not our job to come up with a place for the police to train. We want them to train. We can't live with gunfire anymore.”

Ms. Katz has lived with the noise since she moved into the neighborhood and says she’ll never forget the first time she heard it. Not long after she first moved in, she decided to take a run around the reservoir, an “iconic feature” of Highland Park.

Advertise with us

Her excitement to enjoy the amenities of her neighborhood’s public park didn’t last long. Rounds of gunfire suddenly disrupted her run.

“They were really loud, and I panicked, and I thought, ‘Am I imagining this? What's happening here?’” she said. 

She found a bench and was prepared to duck behind it, asking someone nearby, “Did you hear that? What’s going on?” 

The person told her it was the firing range. 

It’s a part of everyday life for Ms. Katz and other residents. About two months ago, she created a petition on Change.org. 

Advertise with us

“The community council had communicated with the police and had tried to reach out to the mayor,” she said. “So I just thought, well, it doesn't seem like the neighbors have spoken up yet. I'll just start a petition.”

It’s now up to about 1,025 signatures – over double the 500 signatures she was hoping for. 

“I couldn't believe it,” she said. “Everyone was so supportive. We want the police to be trained. This isn't a petition against that. It’s about gunfire.”

She says it’s not just the Highland Park neighborhood subjected to the noise, it’s people across the city who visit the park.

“The sound carries a really long way – a surprisingly long way,” she said. “It's constantly unsettling. And so for people who are visitors to the park who haven't been here before, it can be very shocking. It can cause you to panic. And for people who have lived here for a long time, it has a cumulative effect. I really feel the difference when I leave the neighborhood. My body just feels different.”

Advertise with us

Continual exposure to noise can cause stress, anxiety, depression, high blood pressure, heart disease and other health problems, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. 

She’s especially worried about veterans, refugees and gun violence victims, including survivors of the 2018 synagogue shooting, who live in the area. These groups are vulnerable to conditions such as PTSD, which can cause severe anxiety and strong negative reactions to loud noise. 

And exposure to gun violence itself is a daily reality in the U.S, as firearm injuries and deaths have spiked in recent years. Ms. Katz said her 16-year-old daughter has found the sounds unsettling, as she has participated in active shooter drills in school.

Knowing the gunfire comes from police training doesn’t make it any easier to cope with for anyone, Ms. Katz said.

“We’re managing our lives with these factors because this is how we live now,” she said. “This is how every neighborhood lives now in this country. But this neighborhood has an open air police firing range.”

Advertise with us

Highland Park resident Justin Grotelueschen remembers his children asking about the gunshots once in the park. He moved to Pittsburgh last July with his wife and two children after living in Sri Lanka for 10 years. Since coming to the U.S., he said his kids have learned more about shootings in the news and have taken part in school active shooter drills.

“They have unfortunately had to, you know, learn more about those types of issues,” he said. “My kids were born overseas, so it wasn't something that they had experienced.”

Like Ms. Katz, he also remembers first hearing gunfire from the range during a run around the reservoir. He thought it could have been fireworks, since it was the summer. But when he kept hearing it, and often in the morning, something didn’t add up. 

“When I found out that it was a police shooting range, I'm like, OK, yeah, it makes sense that they would need to have some area in order to practice and in order to, to train. But it seemed odd to me that it was so close to the city and particularly close to this park. It seemed too close for comfort.”

He said conversations around the concerns come up often in that park, particularly among parents concerned about their children’s wellbeing. When he came across Katz’s petition, he was eager to sign off.

Advertise with us

“It seemed like a reasonable request to raise and to have people talk about,” he said. “I understand that the police have a job to do and they need to train in order to do that job. But I don't know why that needs to be here, so close to the city and particularly close to this park. It’s confusing as to why it was allowed to happen.”

For David Klahr, a 50-year resident of Highland Park,the sounds are nothing new. Mr. Klahr,  and a professor emeritus of cognitive development and education science at Carnegie Mellon University, said he turns his hearing aids off when the gunfire starts. 

He estimates he lives about 1,500 feet away from the site. 

“It’s erratic, sometimes it's every day for hours at a time,” Mr. Klahr said. “And then there's periods where there's no firing at all. It'll interfere with your conversation. Often, I’ve tried to guess how many guns are going off. There must be half a dozen to 10 people and they're firing multiple rounds.”

In a 2020 report prepared by Mr. Klahr, and Vivian Loftness, a professor in CMU's school of Architecture, numerous solutions are outlined. 

Advertise with us

Solutions proposed in the proposal included relocating or enclosing the range, reorienting the direction of the shooting to face the steeper slope away from the neighborhood, introducing some kind of shelter to absorb the sounds, publicizing the required trainings and enforcing limited hours.

“There were a lot of very practical suggestions,” he said. “The communication has kind of been one way from the community to a police department, and I don't think anyone from Highland Park has ever had an official visit to the firing range itself to see what it's like.”

After attending last week’s meeting, he remains optimistic his neighborhood will finally see some change. 

“I'm hoping that after the meeting with Mayor Gainey and his staff, as well as people on city council, there's a little more cooperation,” he said. “It's really a problem and impacts the whole demographic of the city, not just the neighbors from the top of the hill in Highland Park.”