A potential merger of Pittsburgh and Wilkinsburg is up for discussion again, but proponents and critics are raising familiar issues.

And if the testimony at a public hearing in Pittsburgh on Saturday is any indication, the sides remain deeply divided.

The Wilkinsburg Community Development Corp., which has led the charge for the borough’s annexation by Pittsburgh, again is in favor of a merger, but many residents appear not to be.

The WCDC began collecting signatures in support of the merger in September and has already surpassed the number needed to move forward in the process.

Advertise with us

It plans to submit the petition to a Common Pleas Court judge — the next step in the possible merger before moving to Pittsburgh City Council and then to the ballot for Wilkinsburg residents — by the end of the year.

“Most people are supportive,” said Tracey Evans, WCDC executive director. “We’ve been studying this and working on this for years. I’ve lived in Wilkinsburg for over 30 years and people have been talking about this from the day I’ve been here.”

Opponents, however, dispute those claims and say the annexation is being pushed by the WCDC and others who have development interests in Wilkinsburg.

The years-long push was temporarily put on hold in July after Wilkinsburg Mayor Marita Garrett and the steering committee behind the merger decided to hold off on a vote in order to gather more public input.

The groups had gathered roughly 800 signatures in support of a merger, meaning the measure had enough support to advance to the court. If a judge approved, it would then go before Pittsburgh City Council for a vote, before appearing on the ballot in November as a referendum.

Advertise with us

Now, advocates for the merger have started a new petition and are aiming to get a referendum on the ballot in the primary election in May.

Ms. Evans wouldn’t disclose the number of signatures on the new petition but said support has been similar to the earlier petition.

Advocates argue that it would boost Pittsburgh’s population, provide more options for schools, improve the quality and accessibility of public services and reduce taxes for residents and businesses.

Ms. Evans said the owner of a home assessed at $100,000 in Wilkinsburg pays nearly double the property taxes that a Pittsburgh homeowner would pay.

“That’s one: taxes,” Ms. Evans said, listing reasons in support of the merger. “It’s also resources. They have so many more resources — especially for homeownership, renter protection, small business support, economic redevelopment ... that we do not have.

Advertise with us

“You pay more, but then what do you get in your services? You get a lot less,” she said. “In order to turn things around, you need to bring back more services.”

Both sides of the annexation argument got to voice their opinions before Pittsburgh City Council on Saturday, as about 40 people — mostly Wilkinsburg residents — spoke at a council hearing on Grant Street about the divisive issue.

Many who support annexation say high property taxes are a problem for the borough.

Madelyn Gioffre said she loves her Wilkinsburg neighborhood and wants to stay, but her taxes are set to double after her most recent home assessment and she may be forced to leave.

“I feel like we are perpetuating this vacant housing problem, and I’m hoping that merging with the city of Pittsburgh and reducing the tax burden will really, really help that issue,” she said.

Advertise with us

Ashley Deeal said in the approximately 20 years she has lived in the borough, she has seen many leaders try to make changes, yet the struggles of the community continue. Annexation, she said, could help streamline the solutions Wilkinsburg needs.

“Through consolidation, I think that Wilkinsburg and Pittsburgh will be able to take advantage of less overhead, more resources and greater efficiencies across the board,” Ms. Deeal said. “I truly believe that we can be stronger together.”

But critics of the merger say Pittsburgh’s public services are already stretched thin and the city can’t accommodate such a quick population boost. And Wilkinsburg could lose some autonomy: A merger would dissolve the mayorship and borough council.

Wilkinsburg Mayor-elect Dontae Comans said he did not believe the merger was in the best interest of WIlkinsburg, noting that the borough has improved its schools and lowered its taxes in recent years.

Mr. Comans told City Council that he believed the push was being rushed and not driven by facts. He said joining the city would not necessarily help Wilkinsburg with issues such as blight, vacant housing and population loss.

Advertise with us

“Riding through the city you see Knoxville, Arlington, you see the west side, you see the North Side — all these communities that need help,” Mr. Comans said. “It seems like we’re getting the hope that once Wilkinsburg becomes Pittsburgh, we’ll automatically get help before the people that are there already, that need the help already.”

Paul O’Hanlon said that while his property taxes are higher in Wilkinsburg, the majority of Wilkinsburg residents are renters, so lowering taxes would be of no benefit to them.

Echoing Mr. Comans, Mr. O’Hanlon said joining Pittsburgh would not mean Wilkinsburg would see the improvements that proponents of the annexation say would follow.

“Look at Homewood, Larimer, West End, Sheraden, Elliott, Central North Side. The decline of neighborhood business districts is a regional or national problem — it just isn’t a Wilkinsburg problem,” Mr. O’Hanlon said. “A case can be made that our business district is surviving better than some of the city neighborhood business districts.”

Renee Dolney said the idea of annexation has little popular support in the borough and will “fail in a landslide” if put up to a vote.

Advertise with us

“We know that the annexation push is not being driven by the city of Pittsburgh. We know that the only driving force for this is the WCDC and whatever interest it is that they represent,” Ms. Dolney said. “Those interests have nothing to do with the best interests of Wilkinsburg or the city of Pittsburgh.”

Several members of City Council expressed concerns about the merger and what it would mean for the resources that Pittsburgh has to fight blight and other problems.

“I’m not sure annexation’s the right process. I think a merger where the two cities and the two cities’ voters could participate may be a better model than this annexation model, because it short circuits the Pittsburgh voters,” said Councilman Ricky Burgess, who added that the Wilkinsburg mayor and council would be left out of the decision.

Pittsburgh Mayor-elect Ed Gainey reiterated last week that he was talking with Pittsburgh City Council members and other leaders to understand their perspectives on the issue before taking a position.

If a referendum does proceed, Wilkinsburg residents should make “this important decision about the future of their community themselves,” a spokesperson for Mr. Gainey said Thursday.

Advertise with us

At a forum last month, Mr. Gainey said he would take his cues on annexation from Mr. Comans. If Wilkinsburg residents want to join Pittsburgh, he said, they need to convince their mayor.

“That’s their ability — to talk to Mayor Comans and get his support,” Mr. Gainey said. “And if they can’t, then there’s no need to have a conversation.”

In the months since the last petition, the biggest change revolves around the school districts, Pittsburgh City Controller Michael Lamb said.

Already, Wilkinsburg students in grades 6-12 are part of Pittsburgh’s Public Schools but a municipal merger would also include a school district merger.

Mr. Lamb, who has supported the merger, doesn’t think that changes much.

Advertise with us

There’s already a lot of overlap between the locations — Pittsburgh and Wilkinsburg work together on garbage collection, fire protection and public school for some grades — so, “we’ve seen what that financial impact can be,” he said.

“As far as the municipal merger, it’s a win-win,” Mr. Lamb said. “It’s an immediate win for taxpayers in Wilkinsburg and…it creates a new dynamic for economic development in the borough of Wilkinsburg.

“On the Pittsburgh side, with that new dynamic, it will really help to grow Pittsburgh’s tax base as well.”

Lauren Rosenblatt: lrosenblatt@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1565. Andrew Goldstein: agoldstein@post-gazette.com or 312-263-1352.