It’s been 25 years since Jonny Gammage, a Black businessman, was stopped in Brentwood by five white police officers.

Mr. Gammage was killed. One officer was eventually acquitted of homicide. The cases of two others ended in mistrials. The two other officers were not charged.

Mr. Gammage’s death on Oct. 12, 1995, was ruled to have been caused by positional asphyxiation, a term familiar to anyone who followed the case of George Floyd, a Black man who died while in police custody in Minneapolis last summer.

The similarities between what happened to Mr. Gammage and what happened to Mr. Floyd don’t end there, as both cases sparked national protests calling for police accountability and racial equality.

Advertise with us

"It's a difficult thing because you look at the civil rights movement, at Martin Luther King, at Marcus Garvey, and all the others who fought so hard, but you feel so frustrated for this to continue to keep happening to us, knowing if the roles were reversed, it wouldn't be this way," Kyna James of the Alliance for Police Accountability, said Saturday, noting that the incidents occurred just 25 years apart.

"When are we going to get the equality we deserve?”

The discussion was part of a panel on Billy Jackson’s documentary “Enough is Enough: The Jonny Gammage Movie.” As part of the 23rd annual Pittsburgh Racial Justice Summit, the panel was hosted by Lynne Hayes-Freeland of KDKA Radio and TV.

This year’s summit, titled “Rise, Revolt, Repeat: Building Sustained Movements for Justice,” was moved online Friday and Saturday due to the pandemic.

Several panelists noted that just before the Gammage case, another death had roiled the community in 1995.

Advertise with us

Jerry Jackson of Hazelwood died after officers fired 51 bullets into his vehicle in the Armstrong Tunnel on April 6, 1995. A white Housing Authority officer pleaded guilty to involuntary manslaughter in 2001. He claimed Mr. Jackson had turned around twice in the tunnel during a chase, forcing him to fire in self-defense.

“The atmosphere around then — it’s very similar to the atmosphere today in terms of being racially charged,” said Khalid Raheem, a community activist and organizer in Pittsburgh, as well as founder and chairman of the New Afrikan Independence Party.

Noting that Dr. Cyril Wecht, then the Allegheny County coroner and a member of Saturday’s panel, introduced the term “positional asphyxiation” 25 years ago and that Mr. Floyd died of asphyxiation this summer, the panel host asked about the frustration many have felt over those years.

Dr. Wecht said there’s “no reason in the world why positional asphyxiation or choke holds have to be used by police.”

Elizabeth Pittinger, executive director of Pittsburgh’s independent Citizen Police Review Board, said training in takedown procedures in Pittsburgh now excludes “the kinds of tactics that would lead to that.”

Advertise with us

But Ms. James said it’s an issue that goes beyond training. “Excessive force is very real. How many officers were standing around when George Floyd said he couldn’t breathe? In that moment, it’s a choice.”

“It’s not like every officer is a bad officer, but for the ones that do things like that, we have to hold them accountable. And when you let officers get away with things like murder, it emboldens others.”

The Gammage case helped bring about the Pittsburgh Citizen Police Review Board. Under a ballot referendum passed in November, the seven-member agency charged with investigating complaints of police misconduct will be empowered under a new charter amendment to require officers to participate in investigations as well as join forces with the city controller to audit the police bureau.

The Alliance for Police Accountability is promoting two other ballot initiatives: Breonna’s Law to ban the use of “no-knock” raids in Pittsburgh and to stop to use of solitary confinement in the Allegheny County Jail.

Stephanie Ritenbaugh: sritenbaugh@post-gazette.com