Most of the 10 city residents who spoke about the Pittsburgh Public Schools budget Monday evening at an open hearing before the school board said they supported the proposed 2.3% tax increase.

But those who came out in opposition — including one school board member who decided to make his opinion public — made it clear that there is still some division.

The hearing at the district office in Oakland came two days before the school board members are scheduled to vote on whether they will adopt the $665.6 million general fund budget for 2020.

“I don’t envy your situation and applaud your willingness to serve,” Michele Traficante, of Brookline, told the school board. “That’s said, let’s talk about your service. Serving your district means voicing the opinions of your constituents. Do your constituents want a property tax increase? The answer is no.”

Advertise with us

The proposed budget calls for a millage increase from 9.84 mills to 10.07 mills, or an additional $23 on every $100,000 of assessed real estate value. This is the first time in five years that the school district is seeking to increase taxes.

The city has the lowest school district millage rate in Allegheny County. The district argues that the tax increase is a necessary step toward correcting its operating deficit.

Those who said they were in favor of the increase said they were concerned about the consequences that would come without the boost in funding from property taxes, such as the cutting of programs, the closure of schools and teachers being furloughed.

“Winning this tax increase will give us breathing room to hold the line against severe cuts,” said Kipp Dawson, a retired city schools teacher who lives in Regent Square. “Then your oversight in the coming months will be essential. I trust that you, our elected school directors, will continue to work with PPS administration to find the most effective and efficient ways to serve our children via the allocation of funds in ways that most effectively and efficiently meet the needs of our children and their schools.”

Holly Cox, the mother of two Pittsburgh Public Schools students, said she was “astonished” when she found out that the city’s school district tax millage was the lowest in Allegheny County. She urged the board to vote for the tax increase so that district schools can get the funding they need.

Advertise with us

“There are arguments against raising taxes — curbing current spending is a big one,” Ms. Cox said. “Looking at no-bid contracts and travel expenditures may save some money, but it won’t be enough when faced with unfunded state and federal mandates.”

School board President Sylvia Wilson said she understands that there are some people who will never want to have their taxes raised. But she said she will vote to approve the budget with the tax increase because she feels its what is best for the students.

“We want to make sure to provide what’s best for our kids and give them every opportunity possible,” Ms. Wilson said. “We don’t want to see them cutting out arts and music and gym and instrumental music and sports activities. We want to be able to provide the best overall curriculum to give them the best experiences possible.”

Board member Sala Udin, who wrote that he would vote against the budget and tax increase in an op-ed that appeared Monday in the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, said nothing he heard at the hearing changed his mind, and he wants more specifics about how a tax increase would actually help students.

He said it would behoove district administration to provide the public and the school board with “a well-thought-out narrative about what we’re currently spending, where we’re falling short, how much we need to raise taxes by, what those taxes will go forward to, and how those taxes are going to ensure the children are better educated.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Udin acknowledged that he shares the concerns that others have about issues like teacher furloughs, but he said his focus remains firmly on student performance, which has been below average over the past several years.

“I’m not here to do anything other than educate children. That’s why we’re here,” he said. “If we don’t see the end result being an improvement in the outcome of educating children, we’re not doing our job.”